Which fighter has the better Resume/Legacy between Mayweather and Calzaghe?

[Bea5T]

Wow...I can tell some of the floyd haters are new to boxing


his resume has been great all throughout his career

especially at lower weights

[Bea5T]

And I dont get why calzaghe gets props for beating b-hop while floyd gets nothing for oscar despite being the much smaller person and th fact that oscar is only 36 and not 43

[warp1432]

What's going on? I thought Parody hated Calzaghe...

This topic though is still Mayweather. Calzaghe has a good resume (him and Hopkins' are really underrated imo), but Mayweather takes the cake on this one. I don't really know who takes the cake of Hopkins and Mayweather's resume. I voted Hopkins before, but I think it's a lot closer now.

[Soundtraveler]

This thread must have been put up as a joke -- because Mayweather (as much as dislike his personality) completely outshines Calzaghe in every catagory you can come up with - it's not even worth mentioning Joe in the same breath as Mayweather - seriously...

[Fox McCloud]

Wow...I can tell some of the floyd haters are new to boxing


his resume has been great all throughout his career

especially at lower weights

His resume at 140 is terrible.

Other than that, really no complaints. He has fought at least one great fight at each weight other than 140.

[The Hammer]

Lmfao that name always gets me Tokker Pudwell, lmfao sounds like a village hall bum fighter lmfao. Mayweather takes this one by a mile.

Common Calzaghe Nuthuggers, I'm English and I love Calzaghe and watching him fight (gave Kessler a lesson) but Floyd would be 1000-0 by now if he fought Tukker Pudwell's to defend his Frank Warren be....I mean WBO belt.

Tocker Pudwill was a late replacement. He came in with a few days notice, because Joe's mandatory opponent was injured in training.

[Sealhound]

Tocker Pudwill was a late replacement. He came in with a few days notice, because Joe's mandatory opponent was injured in training.

You think if Floyd's mandatory was injured, they would find the Tocker Pudwell of the USA to fill the gap! I DON'T think so.. hahah.

That pretty much sums up the thread.