Which fighter has the better Resume/Legacy between Mayweather and Calzaghe?

[C'MONMANG']

Mayweather isn't a five division champ, he's been a five division titleholder. He picks the weakest titleholder in each division and fights them (Baldomir, Gatti) and avoids the best at eash weight class at the time (Morales 130, Mosley 135, Tszyu 140, Cotto 147 and Forrest 154).

Calzaghe is currently the true linear and Ring Champion in two divisions at the same time, something Mayweather has never achieved.

Calzaghe fought the best at 168 - Mayweather avoids the best at 147.

Now Parody will declare a jihad against me again, because I don't agree with his unrealistic, nuthugging view of Floyd. He thinks Floyd is a superman: invincible and perfect!

you actually made some VERY VALID points..

[RichCCFC]

Carlos Baldomir, Zab Judah, Arthuro Gatti?

What the ****?

Does that pass off as a good resume nowadays?

[RichCCFC]

Mayweather isn't a five division champ, he's been a five division titleholder. He picks the weakest titleholder in each division and fights them (Baldomir, Gatti) and avoids the best at eash weight class at the time (Morales 130, Mosley 135, Tszyu 140, Cotto 147 and Forrest 154).

Calzaghe is currently the true linear and Ring Champion in two divisions at the same time, something Mayweather has never achieved.

Calzaghe fought the best at 168 - Mayweather avoids the best at 147.

Now Parody will declare a jihad against me again, because I don't agree with his unrealistic, nuthugging view of Floyd. He thinks Floyd is a superman: invincible and perfect!

Yeah good points Tunney boy, I never actually thought about that.

[Xplosivo]

Carlos Baldomir, Zab Judah, Arthuro Gatti?

What the ****?

Does that pass off as a good resume nowadays?

mario veit, peter manfredo, richie woodhall? evans ashira, sakio bika, kabary salem? tocket pudwill, byron mitchell, will mcIntyre? yeah...some of the weakest title defenses of all time

[muppetman]

I think this is close than what many might think. Calzaghe has defended his 168 lb title 21 times and is a 2 division champ with wins over Lacy, Hopkins, Eubank, Kessler, Veit and Sheikha.

While Mayweather has defended his 130 lb title 9 times and is a 5 division champ at 130, 135, 140, 147 and 154 with wins over Corrales, Castillo, Hatton, Judah, De La Hoya and Hernandez.

Calzaghe has beaten 8 former world champions while Mayweather has beaten 14 former world champions.

Calzaghe has been in the P4P List for almost an year while Floyd has been in the P4P List since 2000 (8 Years) and #1 since 2005 (3 years).

Both have been world champions for 10 years and both are good fighters.

COTTO EASY !!

[C'MONMANG']

mario veit, peter manfredo, richie woodhall? evans ashira, sakio bika, kabary salem? tocket pudwill, byron mitchell, will mcIntyre? yeah...some of the weakest title defenses of all time

the names that he mention were ALL in a ROW execept he was doing Floyd a favor and leaving out SHOT BAY...

WAS gATTI, Shotbay, Judah and Baldo IN A ROW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!LMAO

[the_godslayer]

For me Tunneys point says it all, JC is linear and ring champ in 2 weights at the same time ... NUFF SAID

[Welter_Skelter]

I think this is close than what many might think. Calzaghe has defended his 168 lb title 21 times and is a 2 division champ with wins over Lacy, Hopkins, Eubank, Kessler, Veit and Sheikha.

While Mayweather has defended his 130 lb title 9 times and is a 5 division champ at 130, 135, 140, 147 and 154 with wins over Corrales, Castillo, Hatton, Judah, De La Hoya and Hernandez.

Calzaghe has beaten 8 former world champions while Mayweather has beaten 14 former world champions.

Calzaghe has been in the P4P List for almost an year while Floyd has been in the P4P List since 2000 (8 Years) and #1 since 2005 (3 years).

Both have been world champions for 10 years and both are good fighters.

It's about the same... The P4P thing is irrelavent.. Since it's mainly an American list...
I still might give a slight edge to Mayweather in over all comptetition..

[Jim Jeffries]

mario veit, peter manfredo, richie woodhall? evans ashira, sakio bika, kabary salem? tocket pudwill, byron mitchell, will mcIntyre? yeah...some of the weakest title defenses of all time

I guess you haven't looked at Hopkins' resume.

[RichCCFC]

Mitchell, Sosa, Corley, N'dou, Vargas, Gerena, Juuko etc are all great defences too arent they?