Who won Hopkins vs Calzaghe?

[Chunk..]

I had Calzaghe by a point, 114-113.

Hopkins didn't do enough in the championship rounds, otherwise he'd probably have gotten the nod, but Calzaghe looked the busier fighter.

[Derranged]

Why was this bumped?

Anyone who thinks that fight was a robbery is braindead and/or just mad that the white guy won.

Hate to make "racial" accusations but I think it may apply in some cases.

[Roger Mellie]

The poll result is pretty damn clear. As derranged said,why was this bumped? The racists just need to let this go,accept their guy got beat and move on.

[Sparked_1985]

watching it live I had JC by a point.

But, when I watched it again Zaghe pretty much swept all the rounds from 8 onwards, apart from I think it was 10 when Hopkins cheated, lay down on his back from three minutes and bought himself a massive break. He came out well after that and won the rest of that round.

It wasn't easy but Hopkins basically didn't deserve to win rounds at times - he was too negative. And, basically when you are not initiating any offence of your own for the most part and popping the occassional counter off even if it lands fairly clean, I can't give a fighter that round with a good heart, unless it is a number of shots that exceeds more than a few in a round.

In Football (soccer) terms it's parking 10 men behind the ball for 80 minutes going one-nil down and then still with 10 men largely behind the ball getting a break-away goal. Sure the score is now level but who deserved to win? There were a lot of rounds like this in Calzaghe/Hopkins.

[Weebler I]

The Eurobum beat the American ATG, a triumph of Rocky-esque proportions

[Loddsy]

Had Hopkins on the night but only seen the fight once.

[Deevel916]

If you judge it on who kept busier, then Calzaghe won. If you judge it based on who landed the more signifigant shots, then Bhop won.

I thought Bore Hard was unlucky not to get the nod, but the real loser was anyone who watched it.

[Rome-By-Ko]

Always thought B-Hop won this fight..But I was not mad when they announced that Joey Zags won it...It was all depending on what ya like,work rate was controlled by Joey Zags...The more effective and solid punches(imo)were landed by B-hop..

Great fight imo,I had not issue with the outcome what so ever..

Great fight imo,

Holy ****. Each to their own and all, but...