I rate Joe Calzaghe as P4P number one

[them_apples]

lol what has Calzaghe done to be the top p4p champ? He has hardly beat any recognizable names.

Mayweather has a much more impressive resume, so does Pacquaio. Pacquiao may look like a dieing force but it could be that he's just dieing to make weight, non the less he is still winning.

[FRKO]

Hitler was a great man in my opinion.

Then you are entitled to think that. If it was really your opinion, I'd say "you're a ****ing idiot, in my opinion", but that doesn't mean your opinion is wrong.

Live and let live. Simple as that.

[Left2body]

Pac is over rated, in my opinion. Marquez is better, in my opinion.

No doubt someone will call me a ****ing idiot for saying that, but it's my opinion so I don't give a ****.

No see there is a little thing called a record 1-1-0 is Pac's vs JMM. JMM is 0-1-1. Oppinions have to have some foothold in reality to be taken seriously.

Otherwise its my oppinion I can win the Daytona 500 on my bicycle. .......see common sense and logic dictate that its kinda crazy and that oppinon isn't worth crap. See where I'm going with this?

Certain allowances for oppinon are ok but please be semi-serious.

You dont have to have Cotto as your #1 WW but someone having a current top 5 WW's without Cotto then there list and oppinon on that matter is crap. Same with a current p4p without Pac IN MY OPPINON

[FRKO]

No see there is a little thing called a record 1-1-0 is Pac's vs JMM. JMM is 0-1-1. Oppinions have to have some foothold in reality to be taken seriously.

Otherwise its my oppinion I can win the Daytona 500 on my bicycle. .......see common sense and logic dictate that its kinda crazy and that oppinon isn't worth crap. See where I'm going with this?

Certain allowances for oppinon are ok but please be semi-serious.

You dont have to have Cotto as your #1 WW but someone having a current top 5 WW's without Cotto then there list and oppinon on that matter is crap. Same with a current p4p without Pac IN MY OPPINON

You're welcome to your opinion, brother. Thanks for sharing your views with us.

PS: Please define "reality".

[pelonxsoldier28]

Joe's Up There But #1 P4p He Is Not, Imo

[Easy-E]

floyd mayweather has done nothing for me over the past 4 years. the only good win for me was over zab judah. i thought part timer dlh beat him and don't mention the hatton bout. he is a sliding junior welterweight.

until he beats the likes of vernon forrest ,margarito, williams, quintan and cotto, he will not be number 1 (still top 3). an impressive win over dlh in sep could make him no1 again

Pacman has clearly declined. He has looked a fading force to me since the 2nd erik morales fight. he was very lucky to get the nod against JMM (who is top 5 p4p for me)

Cotto's is number 2 for me based on the opposition he has faced over the past few years. pbf may be too much but we will have to wait and see. He has faced 3 of the best welterweights in the world (mosley, judah, quintanta) and some really dangerous opposition at 140.

Joe Calazaghe is the only man that has been truly outstanding over the past 3 years. He has beat the best in his division in impressive fashion, and has reigned for over 10 years as champ.

My top 5 P4P are:

Calzaghe
Cotto
PBF
Juan Manuel marquez
Pavlik

Terrible list, your biased opinion is irrelevant to the boxing world.

[Easy-E]

If he wins decisively tonight, Joe should be recognized as p4p #1.

Hopkins is BoxRec #1 p4p and Ring #4 p4p.

Go JOE!

Thats not how the p4p list works.
and if he wins decisisvely tonite, he still has no shot at number 1 p4p.
Dont you people know anything.

[Jim Jeffries]

Thats not how the p4p list works.
and if he wins decisisvely tonite, he still has no shot at number 1 p4p.
Dont you people know anything.

If that's not how it works, then how did Hatton get bumped up to like #4 simply by beating Kostya Tszyu and no one else? (he later dropped spots after fighting guys like Urango)

[DiegoFuego]

cong**** TIGEREDGE you're a moron

[DiegoFuego]

You're welcome to your opinion, brother. Thanks for sharing your views with us.

PS: Please define "reality".

Reality is Pacquiao D12 Marquez and Pacquiao W12 Marquez