I rate Joe Calzaghe as P4P number one

[Killa Cam]

I rate TIGEREDGE as mental ******, number one.

[hemichromis]

i agree completely, calzaghe is p4p no1. this would have been recognised alot earlier if he was american.

[Jambo boy]

Not really. P4P lists are opinion, not fact. You can't say someone's opinion is crap, you can only say that you don't agree.

i don't agree

[FRKO]

i don't agree

Good. The world would be a boring place if we all thought the same, like a bunch of soulless clones.

[Pullcounter]

floyd mayweather has done nothing for me over the past 4 years. the only good win for me was over zab judah. i thought part timer dlh beat him and don't mention the hatton bout. he is a sliding junior welterweight.

until he beats the likes of vernon forrest ,margarito, williams, quintan and cotto, he will not be number 1 (still top 3). an impressive win over dlh in sep could make him no1 again

Pacman has clearly declined. He has looked a fading force to me since the 2nd erik morales fight. he was very lucky to get the nod against JMM (who is top 5 p4p for me)

Cotto's is number 2 for me based on the opposition he has faced over the past few years. pbf may be too much but we will have to wait and see. He has faced 3 of the best welterweights in the world (mosley, judah, quintanta) and some really dangerous opposition at 140.

Joe Calazaghe is the only man that has been truly outstanding over the past 3 years. He has beat the best in his division in impressive fashion, and has reigned for over 10 years as champ.

My top 5 P4P are:

Calzaghe
Cotto
PBF
Juan Manuel marquez
Pavlik

nah... only if calzaghe dominates or KTFO hopkins would I even possibly consider him p4p #1 over floyd or pacquiao.

[Jim_Davis]

Im not sure but we will finally have a big arguement with whos the p4p #1? Mayweather, Calzaghe, Pacquiao and Cotto.

[Ray*]

Beating B-hop wouldnt necessarily put Joe C at the top of the tree IMHO, But he isnt far off. Joe has too many mediocre fights at 168 to be top at the moment.

[Fox McCloud]

i agree completely, calzaghe is p4p no1. this would have been recognised alot earlier if he was american.

It definately does not help that he fought in a division dominated by Europeans.

Still though, a lot of his early 168 title defense were against guys who faded into nothing. Eubank, Reid, and a couple of others are really the only ones who had some good success outside of getting a single title shot.

I am one of those people though that find the win over Kessler to be extremely impressive.

[TommyGunn.]

Calzaghe would have a case for #1 P4P if he can beat Hopkins then Pavlik, and pbf still aint fought Cotto. If Joe does that then he'll have owned the top guys from 160/168/175 in 3 fights, never been done before.

Now, Mayweather pretty much has the #1 spot and its not even debatable.

[GTL]

I rate TIGEREDGE as mental ******, number one.

my thoughts exactly