Better resume overall, PBF or Cotto?

[Cobrita]

bALDOMIR........................

Yeah but Baldomir beat Judah before Gayweather and Cotto

[C'MONMANG']

Good post and I agree... but lets look at Emanuel Augustus... this guy is 36-29-6 (19) .... 29 losses... but can still give anyone a run for there money

AND THEN LOSE.....

[C'MONMANG']

Yeah but Baldomir beat Judah before Gayweather and Cotto

So did Spinks and Kostya.......

he's like a door knob, everyone gets a turn. Mosley is getting a turn on May 31st. Don't miss it..

[Cobrita]

So did Spinks and Kostya.......

he's like a door knob, everyone gets a turn. Mosley is getting a turn on May 31st. Don't miss it..

So let me get this straight, since everyone beats Judah then Gayweather and Cotto shouldnt get any credit for beating him? and he stopped Spinks in his hometown for a $100,000

[THE REED]

AND THEN LOSE.....

well obviously... but for years after floyd fought him, floyd continued to say it was his hardest fight... I was just implying that you cant judge a fighter as not being good, just because he has losses.... and anyone that followed his career knows he should have won a lot of his fights. And has been in multiple FOTY...

[!! Shawn]

well obviously... but for years after floyd fought him, floyd continued to say it was his hardest fight... I was just implying that you cant judge a fighter as not being good, just because he has losses.... and anyone that followed his career knows he should have won a lot of his fights. And has been in multiple FOTY...

Augustus is the exception, not the rule.

[C'MONMANG']

So let me get this straight, since everyone beats Judah then Gayweather and Cotto shouldnt get any credit for beating him? and he stopped Spinks in his hometown for a $100,000

AWESOME.

[THE REED]

Augustus is the exception, not the rule.

True. Marg has what 6 losses? hes def. still a threat. altho not exactly 29 lol

[Cobrita]

AWESOME.

I'll take that as a yes, so lets compare the resumes without Judah since Judah sucks and always loses fights:

Mosley
Quintana
Torres
Malignaggi
Pinto

vs

Corrales
Castillo
Hatton
De La Hoya
G. Hernandez

[WHB3]

Floyd's fought 14 former, current, or future champions while Cotto's fought 10. Objectively, you have to give the edge to Floyd.