Better resume overall, PBF or Cotto?

[C'MONMANG']

Apperently if you have a loss on your record...you suck.

IF YOU HAVE 9, YOU SUCK PRETTY BAD,,,,

[!! Shawn]

Apperently if you have a loss on your record...you suck.

No, but fighting very good undefeated fighters is better than fighting very good defeated fighter.

Defeated fighters, by definition, already have a game plan in place to beat them.

And many names on Floyd's resume are over-rated, particularly Castillo and Corrales, thanks in part to their war with each other.

[Cobrita]

Lets see:

Castillo
Corrales
Hatton
De La Hoya
Judah
G. Hernandez
Baldomir
Gatti
Chavez

vs

Mosley
Judah
Quintana
Malignaggi
Torres
Branco
Maussa
Urkal
Pinto

Hmmm...It has to be Cotto guys...It has to be COTTO!!!

[Cobrita]

IF YOU HAVE 9, YOU SUCK PRETTY BAD,,,,

Who had 9 losses?

[!! Shawn]

I just thought of a good analogy. It's like mountain climbing. Climbing Everest is a great achievement, its just not as great an achievement as being the FIRST to climb Everest.

Same mountain, but its already been done.

[THE REED]

No, but fighting very good undefeated fighters is better than fighting very good defeated fighter.

Defeated fighters, by definition, already have a game plan in place to beat them.

And many names on Floyd's resume are over-rated, particularly Castillo and Corrales, thanks in part to their war with each other.

Good post and I agree... but lets look at Emanuel Augustus... this guy is 36-29-6 (19) .... 29 losses... but can still give anyone a run for there money

[FRKO]

I'd say Floyd has the better resume. I haven't checked the poll yet but I'll bet my life on it that everyone else thinks the same.

[C'MONMANG']

Who had 9 losses?

bALDOMIR........................

[Cobrita]

No, but fighting very good undefeated fighters is better than fighting very good defeated fighter.

Defeated fighters, by definition, already have a game plan in place to beat them.

And many names on Floyd's resume are over-rated, particularly Castillo and Corrales, thanks in part to their war with each other.

Werent Corrales and Hatton undefeated when Gayweather fought them?

[!! Shawn]

Good post and I agree... but lets look at Emanuel Augustus... this guy is 36-29-6 (19) .... 29 losses... but can still give anyone a run for there money

I agree, Emanuel Augustus catches people by surprise. However, Mayweather's resume is not filled with Emanuel Augustus type fighter.