Better resume overall, PBF or Cotto?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • C'MONMANG'
    Banned
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Oct 2007
    • 7002
    • 172
    • 21
    • 7,389

    #41
    Originally posted by deliveryman
    And who the has Quintana beaten that all of a sudden makes him so established? Sorry a win over Paul Williams doesn't quite cut it.
    Do I need to start a poll? Who has the better resume, Hatton or Quintana?

    Also, most people thought Oscar won the rematch, and both fights were very close. To use that as an anchor to claim that Cotto's win over Mosley is better than Floyd's win over Oscar is complete and utter bull****, considering it was Floyd's 5th weightclass, and Cotto's 2nd.

    Baldomir was the lineal champion with wins over Gatti and Judah. What has Urkal done? Here I'll answer this for you: Not more than Baldomir.
    a win over Julio and PW DOES CUT it,, CLEAR WINS AS A MATTER OF FACT..

    ITS CUTS IT MORE THEN ALMOST GETTING YOUR HEAD TAKEN OFF BY COLLAZO.....LMAO!!!

    Comment

    • BmoreBrawler
      Undisputed Champion
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Jul 2006
      • 4594
      • 130
      • 315
      • 11,672

      #42
      Originally posted by Ironside
      OK explain to me how

      Mosley
      Judah
      Urkal
      Quintana
      Malignaggi
      Torres

      is better than

      Hatton
      DLH
      Baldomir
      Judah
      Mitchell
      Gatti
      Castillo (x2)
      N'dou
      Corrales
      I voted for Cotto as a protest vote of the poll...

      Comment

      • deliveryman
        Your token white guy
        Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
        • Mar 2006
        • 7592
        • 362
        • 178
        • 15,510

        #43
        Originally posted by c'monmang'
        a win over Julio and PW DOES CUT it,, CLEAR WINS AS A MATTER OF FACT..

        ITS CUTS IT MORE THEN ALMOST GETTING YOUR HEAD TAKEN OFF BY COLLAZO.....LMAO!!!
        Joel Julio who barely squeezed by Rivera? Give me a break.

        Wins over:
        Joel Julio
        Paul Williams

        is better than wins over:
        Tsyzu
        Collazo
        Castillo
        Phillips

        Comment

        • C'MONMANG'
          Banned
          Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
          • Oct 2007
          • 7002
          • 172
          • 21
          • 7,389

          #44
          [QUOTE=Ironside;3287525]OK explain to me how

          Mosley
          Judah
          Urkal
          Quintana
          Malignaggi
          Torres


          is better than

          Hatton
          DLH
          Baldomir
          Judah
          Mitchell
          Gatti
          Castillo (x2)
          N'dou
          Corrales[/QUOTE]

          THE bolded were all undefeated and went on to win titles....

          Comment

          • deliveryman
            Your token white guy
            Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
            • Mar 2006
            • 7592
            • 362
            • 178
            • 15,510

            #45
            [QUOTE=c'monmang';3287571]
            Originally posted by Ironside
            OK explain to me how

            Mosley
            Judah
            Urkal
            Quintana
            Malignaggi
            Torres


            is better than

            Hatton
            DLH
            Baldomir
            Judah
            Mitchell
            Gatti
            Castillo (x2)
            N'dou
            Corrales[/QUOTE]

            THE bolded were all undefeated and went on to win titles....
            You forgot to bold Hatton.

            Comment

            • C'MONMANG'
              Banned
              Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
              • Oct 2007
              • 7002
              • 172
              • 21
              • 7,389

              #46
              Originally posted by deliveryman
              Joel Julio who barely squeezed by Rivera? Give me a break.

              Wins over:
              Joel Julio
              Paul Williams

              is better than wins over:
              Tsyzu
              Collazo
              Castillo
              Phillips
              Hatton BARELY squeezed by Collazo..whats your point.

              NObody oN haTTOns list beats PW...or Quitana..too small TOO OLD!!

              Comment

              • deliveryman
                Your token white guy
                Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                • Mar 2006
                • 7592
                • 362
                • 178
                • 15,510

                #47
                Originally posted by c'monmang'
                Hatton BARELY squeezed by Collazo..whats your point.

                NObody oN haTTOns list beats PW...or Quitana..too small TOO OLD!!
                Oh god... You're just asking for it.

                Comment

                • C'MONMANG'
                  Banned
                  Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                  • Oct 2007
                  • 7002
                  • 172
                  • 21
                  • 7,389

                  #48
                  [QUOTE=deliveryman;3287576]
                  Originally posted by c'monmang'

                  You forgot to bold Hatton.

                  which one of the guys in Cott's list moved up in weight JUST for the fight with him. then went RIGHT back down?

                  I thought Collazo beat Hatton? didnt he? oh...

                  Comment

                  • !! Shawn
                    !! Shown
                    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                    • Dec 2007
                    • 9810
                    • 670
                    • 724
                    • 31,455

                    #49
                    Miguel Cotto, because he has fought 5 undefeated fighters compared to only 2 for Mayweather.

                    Carlos Maussa 17-0
                    Kelson Pinto 21-0
                    Ricardo Torres 28-0
                    Paulie Malignaggi 21-0
                    Carlos Quintana 23-0

                    Mayweather has only fought 2 undefeated fighters in his whole career.

                    Diego Corrales
                    Ricky Hatton

                    Comment

                    • warp1432
                      the mailman
                      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                      • Jul 2007
                      • 14406
                      • 478
                      • 347
                      • 24,060

                      #50
                      Apperently if you have a loss on your record...you suck.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP