Better resume overall, PBF or Cotto?

[deliveryman]

cmonmang is an ANTI-floyd nuthugger. Yes, I am one of the few sane ones.

Yeah, you're one of the sane ones who thought Oscar won the first fight, yet criticize Floyd for taking a rematch.

[C'MONMANG']

Floyd's resume at 147 or above is just as good as Cotto's, if not better.

Cotto:
Mosley
Judah
Quintana
Urkal

Mayweather:
Mitchell
Judah
Baldomir
Oscar
Hatton

Direct comparison between wins:
Mosley = De La Hoya
Judah = Judah
Hatton > Quintana
Baldomir > Urkal.

Hatton could BARELY surive against Collazo, yet you say he beats Quintana..lol

bALDO > OVER ANYONE is a joke!!

Mosley > Dela TWICE!!

[sparked_85]

Hatton could BARELY surive against Collazo, yet you say he beats Quintana..lol

bALDO > OVER ANYONE is a joke!!

Mosley > Dela TWICE!!

But Hatton is a name.

Man I though it was you Americans who were all about names.

[Parody]

Thank god you made this public so we could see who voted for Cotto

[Ironside]

cmonmang is an ANTI-floyd nuthugger. Yes, I am one of the few sane ones.

OK explain to me how

Mosley
Judah
Urkal
Quintana
Malignaggi
Torres

is better than

Hatton
DLH
Baldomir
Judah
Mitchell
Gatti
Castillo (x2)
N'dou
Corrales

[C'MONMANG']

But Hatton is a name.

Man I though it was you Americans who were all about names.

lol................

[Xplosivo]

OK explain to me how

Mosley
Judah
Urkal
Quintana
Malignaggi
Torres

is better than

Hatton
DLH
Baldomir
Judah
Mitchell
Gatti
Castillo (x2)
N'dou
Corrales

I would also add Genaro Hernandez in that list

[BmoreBrawler]

Yeah, you're one of the sane ones who thought Oscar won the first fight, yet criticize Floyd for taking a rematch.

because there was no demand for the rematch, no one besides Manny Steward, Floyd Mayweather Sr., Tom Kacsmarek(sp?), myself, and the lurkers who send me pm's in agreement every time I make that claim thought it was a robbery, and it was clear that Floyd could have beaten Oscar badly in that fight if he had the balls to do it.

[deliveryman]

Hatton could BARELY surive against Collazo, yet you say he beats Quintana..lol

bALDO > OVER ANYONE is a joke!!

Mosley > Dela TWICE!!

And who the has Quintana beaten that all of a sudden makes him so established? Sorry a win over Paul Williams doesn't quite cut it.

Do I need to start a poll? Who has the better resume, Hatton or Quintana?

Also, most people thought Oscar won the rematch, and both fights were very close. To use that as an anchor to claim that Cotto's win over Mosley is better than Floyd's win over Oscar is complete and utter bull****, considering it was Floyd's 5th weightclass, and Cotto's 2nd.

Baldomir was the lineal champion with wins over Gatti and Judah. What has Urkal accomplished? Here I'll be nice and answer this one for you to save the embarrassment: A lot less than Baldomir.

[C'MONMANG']

OK explain to me how

Mosley
Judah
Urkal
Quintana
Malignaggi
Torres

is better than

Hatton
DLH
BaldomirJudah
Mitchell
Gatti
Castillo (x2)
N'dou
Corrales

LMAO... you people kill me!!! lol LOL