what will it take to get mayweather off the #1 p4p spot??

[RichCCFC]

Calzaghe beating Hopkins and Pavlik.

[tredh]

Truth be told if PBF continues on this path he will drop from the top spot in P4P rankings but that still doesn't mean he isn't the most skilled fighter. It just means other P4P fighter have been fighting more meaningful fights.

How much a fighter excites the crowd has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with where said fighter is ranked P4P.

[C'MONMANG']

Truth be told if PBF continues on this path he will drop from the top spot in P4P rankings but that still doesn't mean he isn't the most skilled fighter. It just means other P4P fighter have been fighting more meaningful fights.

How much a fighter excites the crowd has ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to do with where said fighter is ranked P4P.

Who he beats tho is...


P4P is an opinion. period.

[K-Nan]

He has to lose.

[ATFsven]

i dont get how pound for pound rankings can be done on excitement or crowd response or popularity etc etc. that has nowt to do with how gifted a FIGHTER someone is.

[Gareth Ivanovic]

PBCS dictates that you may be a nuthugger.

LOL! It seems JoartCC and Viva have passed on to you those PBCS senses.

[BmoreBrawler]

i have just noticed a massive flaw in my reasoning tho...

if calz did infact beat hops and pav then i suppose he would also be technically skilled up the ass.. ****

exactly. Big wins are better evidence for skill than what our untrained eyes see.

[tredh]

Who he beats tho is...


P4P is an opinion. period.

Of course to the bold which is why I said he if he continues on his current path he will drop.

[2501]

a loss to Big Show

[Shalafi]

He has to lose.

Yeah but how can arguably the most skilled boxer of our era lose by fighting guys who pose no real threat to him? how can he be called #1 p4p when he hasn't fought any good opposition the last 3-4 years. And PLEASE do not say Ricky Hatton or Oscar, PLEASE!!!