ATG status considering Wladimir?

[Slotff]

If Wlad can do this in the rest of his carreer I say he is top 15 of all time.

Beat (in this orderish):

Tony Thompson
Alexander Povetkin
Ruslan Chagaev or Nikolai Valuev (1)
Samuel Peter
David Haye
John Ruiz or Andrew Golota or Hasim Rahman (2)
Alexander Demitrienko

1= Rematch winner
2= HoFer (yes old though)

In short, the competition isn't around to make Wladimir an all time great. The skill is, for sure, he has tremendous skill, not the opponents though. If he beats those guys he has cleaned out though.

[Horus]

Compare Wlad Record to any GREAT HW of All time


Before anybody ask this Question again..

[squealpiggy]

I don't like rating active fighters all time, but seeing as you asked the question, how do you think Klitschko would do against these guys:

Muhammad Ali
Rocky Marciano
Mike Tyson
Joe Frazier
Joe Louis
Lennox Lewis
George Foreman
Sonny Liston
Floyd Patterson

I'd even pick Jack Dempsey to hammer Klitschko despite the disparity in height and weight.

[Addison]

Is he there yet through unifying and disposing of more then 10+ top 10 heavyweight contenders, as well as being the most dominant champ of the latter part of the 21st century.

OR

Does he still have to unify all the belts.

Who decides, and where is the line drawn.

I'm sorry.. Is the question "Is Wladimir Klitchsko an ATG?"