Who has the most impressive resume, Mayweather or DLH?

[Steak]

if yall are going to put names like Sharmba Michell and Zab Judah on Floyd's 'best wins' list, you may as well put Campas, Carr, Gonzalez, Leija, Hernandez, and Ruelas on De La Hoya's 'best wins' list too.

they both have really great records, but lets face it, De La Hoya's is better.
at 130, Oscar fought two undefeatd fighters that werent too good to Floyd's Corrales, Hernandez, Manfredy, Chavez
At 135 Oscar beat Ruelas, Paez, Molina, Leija, Hernandez to Floyds Castillo x2(one was a very close fight), Ndou...
At 140 Oscar beat old Chavez, 41-0 Gonzalez to Floyds Gatti and Corley
At 147 Oscar beat Whitaker(very close fight), Camacho, old Chavez, Quartey(close fight), Oba Carr, Trinidad, Gatti to Floyd's Hatton, Judah, Mitchell, Baldomir
At 154 Oscar beat Castillego, Vargas, Campas, Mosley, Mayorga to Floyd's Oscar
At 160 neither beat anyone

pick and choose

[BmoreBrawler]

The implications of this thread are that Oscar is more of an ATG than Floyd and is the greatest fighter of this generation over floyd and probably Evan Fields.

[-Hyperion-]

oscar would be 39-0(38KO) vs floyd's opposition....


(the only one who would go the distance would be his older version)

[warp1432]

if yall are going to put names like Sharmba Michell and Zab Judah on Floyd's 'best wins' list, you may as well put Campas, Carr, Gonzalez, Leija, Hernandez, and Ruelas on De La Hoya's 'best wins' list too.

they both have really great records, but lets face it, De La Hoya's is better.
at 130, Oscar fought two undefeatd fighters that werent too good to Floyd's Corrales, Hernandez, Manfredy, Chavez
At 135 Oscar beat Ruelas, Paez, Molina, Leija, Hernandez to Floyds Castillo x2(one was a very close fight), Ndou...
At 140 Oscar beat old Chavez, 41-0 Gonzalez to Floyds Gatti and Corley
At 147 Oscar beat Whitaker(very close fight), Camacho, old Chavez, Quartey(close fight), Oba Carr, Trinidad, Gatti to Floyd's Hatton, Judah, Mitchell, Baldomir
At 154 Oscar beat Castillego, Vargas, Campas, Mosley, Mayorga to Floyd's Oscar
At 160 neither beat anyone

pick and choose

The ****? Hatton was a lot better then Gatti anyday at 147. You can't compare those wins at all. Hatton was undefeated and had a great name on his resume.

I agree Oscar has the better resume, but people underrate Floyd's resume.

[DrewWoodside]

DLH does, problem is he lost a bunch of the fights.. Question is would Mayweather have won so much if he took on these types.

[Steak]

The ****? Hatton was a lot better then Gatti anyday at 147. You can't compare those wins at all. Hatton was undefeated and had a great name on his resume.

I agree Oscar has the better resume, but people underrate Floyd's resume.

I sure as hell never said that Gatti was a better win than Hatton, did I? In fact, I gave you the choice to choose who did better at what weights. I sure as hell thought Floyd had a way better record at 130 than Oscar...but I actualy do think Oscar has a better record at 147, why? because
Whitaker(very close fight), Camacho, old Chavez, Quartey(close fight), Oba Carr, Trinidad, Gatti is better than Hatton, Judah, Mitchell, Baldomir

[warp1432]

Oh right I misread lol. Pwned I guess.

And Oscar does have a better resume (by far) at 147, but Floyd's at 147 is good for only being there 4 fights.

[wmute]

Oscar by a WIDE margin. I don't see a single Mayweather opponent that would pose any problems for Oscar. Mayweather would definitely have problems and would probabbly avoid some of Oscar's opponents. Mayweather is undefeated and I give him props for that, Oscar has losses because he took risks against better or evenly matched fighters. Oscar didn't have to fight the fighters he did, but he did and in the process set himself up for a possible defeat. Oscar would be without a doubt and I challenge anyone to dispute the fact that if Oscar fought Floyds opponents ,Oscar would also be undefeated.

I can see DLH beating everyone in FMJ Resume. I can not say that the other way around.

DLH

Does the word ”size“ mean anything to you?

[wmute]

Let's use your logic and apply that to fake Floyd.

Too bad Fake Floyd ducked 90% of the fights that mattered.

Very good logic wmute may I say.

Very very good.

Village idiot, lots of time at your hands? Not so busy with your important activities?

[FantasticFloyd]

FLoyd Mayweather Jr. has the more impressive resume. One thing, he is undefeated and didn't lose to any of his opponents while Oscar lost every big fight he has ever been in. Floyd's been in many big fights throughout his career, but is still undefeated and has beat all elite competition who have stepped his way.