Who has the most impressive resume, Mayweather or DLH?

[Tuggers1986]

And quite a lot of people say Mayweather lost to Israel Castillo the first time.

He did.

without a doubt. by ATLEAST 1 point. I say 2.

[Fox McCloud]

And quite a lot of people say Mayweather lost to Israel Castillo the first time.

Jose Luis Castillo?

Typo or is that a nickname or what?

[Silencers]

Jose Luis Castillo?

Typo or is that a nickname or what?

A joke.

[Tuggers1986]

Jose Luis Castillo?

Typo or is that a nickname or what?

It's our name for JLC. haha

[Fox McCloud]

It's our name for JLC. haha

*******.

Anyways, I think you are being a bit harsh on Oscar saying he lost all his big fights.

He has quite a few names on his resume that had better careers than probably everyone on Mayweather's resume.

Has anyone Mayweather fought done as well with their career as Julio Cesar Chavez? How about Pernell Whitaker? The only problem with these guys are that they were past their prime.

Oscar beat up a prime Fernando Vargas when he moved up to 154.

Oscar beat a prime Ike Quartey at 147, who was considered to be a serious contender for best at that weight, as much so as Trinidad and De La Hoya.

Genaro Hernandez (even though he isn't really relevant to resume comparison with Mayweather) and Hector Camacho are two other pretty damn good wins on Oscar's resume.

I do think that you don't get to just ignore losses on a resume though. Regardless of those good wins above, I do think that Oscar loses points for losing to Trinidad, Mosley, Mosley, Hopkins and Mayweather. Those aren't neutral fights, they are negatives to his resume.

[ElGranLuchador]

oscar for sure he always fought the best out there
unlike mayweather

[Fox McCloud]

oscar for sure he always fought the best out there
unlike mayweather

Jake Rodriguez fought Felix Trinidad, Pernell Whitaker and Kostya Tszyu.

Does that mean he has a better resume than Floyd?

[Silencers]

*******.

Anyways, I think you are being a bit harsh on Oscar saying he lost all his big fights.

He has quite a few names on his resume that had better careers than probably everyone on Mayweather's resume.

Has anyone Mayweather fought done as well with their career as Julio Cesar Chavez? How about Pernell Whitaker? The only problem with these guys are that they were past their prime.

Oscar beat up a prime Fernando Vargas when he moved up to 154.

Oscar beat a prime Ike Quartey at 147, who was considered to be a serious contender for best at that weight, as much so as Trinidad and De La Hoya.

Genaro Hernandez (even though he isn't really relevant to resume comparison with Mayweather) and Hector Camacho are two other pretty damn good wins on Oscar's resume.

I do think that you don't get to just ignore losses on a resume though. Regardless of those good wins above, I do think that Oscar loses points for losing to Trinidad, Mosley, Mosley, Hopkins and Mayweather. Those aren't neutral fights, they are negatives to his resume.

But people know that DLH won the Trinidad fight and the second fight with Mosley, he lost to Hopkins at middleweight where DLH didn't belong.

DLH's only legit losses were Mosley 1, Hopkins, Mayweather. The Sturm fight should have been a loss too.

[tyson]

Jake Rodriguez fought Felix Trinidad, Pernell Whitaker and Kostya Tszyu.

Does that mean he has a better resume than Floyd?

Unlike DLH, he was probably not competitive in those fights...

[MissDeeCole]

mayweather has a resume for putting my ass to sleep...