Which fights did Oscar Dela Hoya actually win or lose ?

[Dynamite Kid]

whitaker- draw
quartey- quartey won
trinidad- de la hoya won
mosley 2- de la hoya won
sturm- sturm won
mayweather- pbf won

the only thing we disagree then is the Trinidad fight ,would u concede that it was'nt a robbery by any stretch though even if Oscar did win

[Mr. Unbannable]

Whitaker W
Quartey W
Trinidad W
Mosley1 L
Mosley2 W
Sturm W
Mayweather L

[Dynamite Kid]

Whitaker W
Quartey W
Trinidad W
Mosley1 L
Mosley2 W
Sturm W
Mayweather L

he beat Sterm & Quartey did he have a day off fella ,maybe in the record books but no in reallity he did'nt

[Thread Stealer]

the only thing we disagree then is the Trinidad fight ,would u concede that it was'nt a robbery by any stretch though even if Oscar did win

i had dlh narrowly ahead.

there were some close rounds before oscar got tired and ran.

round 1, round 4, round 8, even round 9 was close.

[Dynamite Kid]

i had dlh narrowly ahead.

there were some close rounds before oscar got tired and ran.

round 1, round 4, round 8, even round 9 was close.

well why do people claim it was a robbery i just dont get it it was a close fight when the final bell went

[Scott9945]

i guess a few Hysterical women screaming & Oscar flurrying & missing with punches & then getting on his bike catches peoples eyes eh

You got that right. The only dog reference should be Oscar running like one.

[Dynamite Kid]

the reasons Oscar lost some of his biggest fights IMO are because he fought to tactically & tentitively at times and i think it conspired against him ,obviously his bad stamina played a huge roles aswell

[Scott9945]

Which fights did Oscar actually win or lose ?

Whitaker D
Quartey L
Mayweather L
Mosley 2 w
Trinidad L
Sterm


i thought the Whitaker fight was a Draw but the scoring was distorted some what by the Knockdown that never was against Oscar & that point Whitaker had deducted for a Head butt where the rules stated that the fighter should be punished for headbutts regardless wether it was an Accident or not ,it depends no how u view these 2 situations IMO Oscar did'nt do enough in the second half of the fight to take Whtakers title but in the same token Whitaker never defended his title like a Champion either ,i thought Whitaker fought way to passive to win the fight very rarely did he assert himself & show willing to win the victory ,therefore i had it a draw

i thought Oscar lost to Quartey by about 2/3 rounds although he did finish very strongly & scored 2 knockdowns he was actually knocked down in the same round as Quartey so that equals that round up a bit

i thought he beat Mosley in the second fight, allthough his customary bad stamina showed up late in the fight & Shane came on strong towards the end i still had Oscar doing enough in the 1st part of the fight to win the decision

contrary to popular belief i did'nt think he was robbed against Trinidad ,he lost that fight because he threw it away & he let Trinidad back in to the fight ,i would'nt say Trinidad deserved to win either but it was'nt a robbery & if anything i think the momentum Trindad had going towards the end of the fight swung it his way ,i would have scored it a draw or 1 round to Tito if i had to pick a winner i did'nt think Oscar deserved the win especially when u condsider the way he fought the last part of the fight

the Floyd fight was close untill Oscar stamina problems showed up again & he stopped jabbing ,i had Floyd winnig by about 2 rounds i think

im not sure what to say about the Sterm fight Oscar was quite active in that fight but he did get caught a hell of a lot ill let u decide on that one

who did u have winning these fights

Whitaker-Won
Quartey-Won
Trinidad-Draw
Mosley 1&2-Lost
Sturm-Lost
Mayweather-Lost

[Thread Stealer]

well why do people claim it was a robbery i just dont get it it was a close fight when the final bell went

people cry robbery whenever they disagree with a decision.

just start any thread and say "biggest robbery ever" and watch the clowns put in a fight where one guy should have won 115-114.

if you want to see a real robbery watch holyfield-lewis 1, escalera-everett, or coggi-gonzalez 1.

if you want to see a close decision that could have gone either way and then have people cry robbery, watch mosley-dlh 2, taylor-hopkins, or dlh-whitaker.

[Dynamite Kid]

people cry robbery whenever they disagree with a decision.

just start any thread and say "biggest robbery ever" and watch the clowns put in a fight where one guy should have won 115-114.

if you want to see a real robbery watch holyfield-lewis 1, escalera-everett, or coggi-gonzalez 1.

if you want to see a close decision that could have gone either way, watch mosley-dlh 2, taylor-hopkins, or dlh-whitaker.

aint that the truth thread stealer