who won Dela Hoya v Whitaker

[Darkstar]

Whatever the poll says, it's still true that Whitaker had to knock DLH out to get a win. The judges scorecards were ridiculous and the point taken from the 'headbutt' was unwarranted.

It was repaid and then some. Whitaker was given a knockdown credit for a off balance slip.

[TheGreatA]

It was repaid and then some. Whitaker was given a knockdown credit for a off balance slip.

De La Hoya went down from a punch, it wasn't much but he was caught by a punch (wasn't very clean, looked more like a forearm to me).

The KD was legit but only technical. I've seen many of those, the most ridiculous KD I've seen was in the Santa Cruz vs Casamayor fight.

I wouldn't have scored it a KD if I was the ref though. The referee and the judges were awful in that fight.

[BmoreBrawler]

Oscar beat Mayweather in a close one, Whitaker beat Oscar in a close one.

[Darkstar]

What you said before was that if the round was close it should go to the aggressor. That is exactly what you said which is complete bull****. Like I said my question had nothing to do with the De la Hoya vs Whitaker. It was totally based on PBF vs. Hatton. I wanted to know your opinion on that fight and that fight only. I already know how you felt about Whitaker vs. De la Hoya.

Again what are the reasons you scored those rounds for Hatton. If you don't want to answer or can't remember just say so. **** ain't going make or break anything.

I didn't say I maybe gave one round to Hatton. I was basically saying that I gave Hatton 1 round for sure with the possibility of him maybe winning some others.

I dont remember the exact rounds but I did give him a few. The were in the frist half of the fight. The reasons why I didnt give him all (even tho he was the aggressor). He was posing no threat to Mayweather and being hit with solid clean blows.

[tredh]

I dont remember the exact rounds but I did give him a few. The were in the frist half of the fight. The reasons why I didnt give him all (even tho he was the aggressor). He was posing no threat to Mayweather and being hit with solid clean blows.

Cool thats all I wanted to know.

BmoreBrawler you trippin if you think De la Hoya won that fight.

[BmoreBrawler]

Cool thats all I wanted to know.

BmoreBrawler you trippin if you think De la Hoya won that fight.

Not if you take into account that Mayweather landed maybe half of the punches that compubox gave him.

[tredh]

Not if you take into account that Mayweather landed maybe half of the punches that compubox gave him.

If you look at it that you could say that De la Hoya landed even less than what it had for him also. Why would compubox be wrong for PBF but right for De la Hoya?

[-Hyperion-]

de la hoya won very clearly, the people who think this was a robbery are the same type of guys who scored de leon-escobedo for escobedo...

[Slotff]

I thought de la Hoya won 8 rounds against Whitaker, so like 116-111, and I had him barely beating Mayweather at 115-114 6-5-1