Underrated/Overrated Active Fighters

[Scott9945]

Underrated: Juan Carlos Gomez, Martin Castillo

Overrated: Oscar De La Hoya, Zab Judah

[Addition]

Overrated - Paul Williams

Underrated - Joshua Clottey

[RichCCFC]

Overrated - Paul Williams

Underrated - Joshua Clottey

Good picks.

I also think Juan Diaz is underrated and Anthony Mundine.

[ElGranLuchador]

underrated: ulises solis joan guzman
overrated<. hopkins and wirght

[mrpain81]

Overrated

SAMUEL PETER
Joe Calzaghe - He's very good but some people have him P4P #1
Miguel Angel Cotto - See Emanuel Steward and Floyd haterz


Underrated

GLEN JOHNSON
ROMAN KARMAZIN
CRISTIAN MIJARES
JOSE SANTA CRUZ

[Tuggers1986]

Underrated

Vernon Forrest

Overrated

Jermain Taylor

[Randall_Hopkirk]

Overrated - Paul Williams

Underrated - Joshua Clottey

Spot on. The notion that every welterweight in the world is scared of Paul Williams is amusing. Clottey would rip him a new ass hole.

[Randall_Hopkirk]

Underrated: Jorge Linares, David Haye, Josh Clottey, Clinton Woods.
Overrated: Paul Malignaggi, Paul Williams, Chad Dawson.

[-Swizzy-]

Underrated

Kelly Pavlik - he ko'd jermaine taylor, something hopkins, wright and spinks couldn't do. he took some brutal power shots from miranda and pulled through to ko him and he is still not a top 5 p4p for most ppl.

Vernon Forrest - in Mosley's prime, he schooled him. has only lost to 1 fighter. probably has the best chance from anybody to beat mayweather. yet once again, on nobody's p4p list.

Overrated
Joe Calzaghe - I like him but, 2 or 3 p4p? I don't think so. His best oponent thus far has been Kessler who is another question mark cuz who has kessler beat. He is in one of the weakest divisions talent wise. that division could be dominated by any one of the top 5 middleweights and light heavyweights at the moment.

Margarito - lost to: Daniel Santos, Rodney Jones, Larry Dixon, Victor Lozoya. The most feared man? I think not.

oh and one that I forgot in my underrated section. Junior Witter. Its really not fair for him cuz Hatton isn't giving him a shot. Witter is by far the best jr welterweight. If he were a welterweight, and the top fighters would fight him, he would be a top 4 welterweight garunteed and getting the recognition that he deserves. A wonderful talent and great to watch. Look him up on youtube or anywhere, and you will see what I'm talking about.

[RichCCFC]

Overrated - Kelly Pavlik

He had a lucky win over the GREAT champions Taylor... The fight should of been stopped in the second.