P4P #2? Calzaghe or Pacquiao?

[RichCCFC]

I think Bernards prime came when he fought Glen Johnson or Ecols, I think that was atleast 3-5 years after the Jones fight.

Back to topic now?

[K-Nan]

Kessler won multiple belts and beat multiple champs. Do you really think the Hopkins Jones fought is as good as today's Kessler? Wait and see what Kessler does next. The man is real.

But this it irrelevant. Calz is not as good as JOnes was

Exactly. Also- I could skew it just as much by saying that the Hopkins that Joe is gonna fight is not as good as the one Roy fought.

[sterling]

hmmm i duno pac is hungrey but so is joe i have no idea whos 2 but who ever wins there next fight wil defo be number 2 i hope they both keep there hunger.

[kayjay]

Exactly. Also- I could skew it just as much by saying that the Hopkins that Joe is gonna fight is not as good as the one Roy fought.

You could say that.

[OptimusWolf]

I think Pacman has certainly got the better wins on his resume, with barrera and Morales plus a draw with JMM, and Larios and Hussein.

Joe has no losses (and has fought a few guys, particularly Kessler and Eubank, who would give anyone at 168 trouble, inc even Jones and Toney) and looks pretty impressive when he fights top opposition.

Overall it has to go to Pac, but he need a good win against JMM or if Calzaghe beats old poppa hopkins he'll usurp the little pinoy.

[RichCCFC]

Tied again!

[Chups]

Definitely Joe Calzaghe.

[Pugilistic™]

i give it to calzaghe.

pacman gets it if he beats marquez

[Parody]

No, I just think Roy could of fought far more people than he made out where as Joe could only have fought limited fighters with their drawing powers.For a fighter who is often compared to Leonard and Robinson his resume isn't that great.

Anyway, back to the topic at hand if we may?

1. Roy Jones beat better Opposition than Calzaghe.
2. Roy Jones is a better fighter than Calzaghe.
3. Joe Calzaghe is a very good fighter, Roy Jones is a legend.

End of thread.

[BHONN]

Pacman is mandatory #2 p4p...
Joe is an overrated fighter that incomparable to Roy Jones....
those people comparing Joe to Roy is a blind Joe nuthugger...