More impressive: Pea-Chavez or PBF-Chico?

[Fox McCloud]

Also, I had Whitaker winning by a round, while Mayweather TKO'd Corrales. That is def. more impressive. Also, JCC had a padded record of nobodies in Mexico. Maybe 10 of his 80 some fights were against non-cab drivers.

I'm glad someone else didn't see an absolutely through outclassing by Whitaker like everyone else did. I thought Whitaker was winning the rounds, but I didn't think he was dominating the **** out of them.

[Maxy]

Chavez would have destroyed Corrales....broken him in half, so the comparison between performances isn't a good one.

Of course PBF dominated Corrales more emphatically than Whitaker beat Chavez but at the end of the day Whitaker is better than all of them.

[Thread Stealer]

chavez is an atg while corrales was a very good fighter, but was chavez better at welterweight than chico was at 130?

[TonyJ]

With all respect, Chico was a very limited fighter. He couldn't use his reigh-advantage and was average boxer in terms of skill. He had real power at SFW, but hey this is below the LW-division. You can't be a great SFW-fighter based on your power.
It was a good win for Mayweather, no doubt. He fought a perfect fight so i don't wanna take anythink away from him BUT this fight was more like Calzaghe-Lacy with Corrales being nothing more than a SFW-version of LAcy. He was very unproven in my mind, and i don't think than his style can make Mayweather problems.
JCC was a great fight, over the hill but he was great. He was a awesome pressure-fighter, and it's way tougher for a slickster to outbox a real skilled pressure fighter than a brawler/puncher like Corrales.
The Whitaker/CHavez fight was much closer, so this is a point for Floyd. But in the end of the day i would go with Whitaker.

[Kc-hoodsta]

u guys are ****ing ridicoulous man LOOK at the records of the people JCC was facing they weren't bums in his third fight he got the vacant WBC super featherweight and by 87 he got the WBA lightweight title maybe to all u guys u don't recognize people but someone who is up on they mexican boxing will recognize edwin"chapo" rosario

ruben castillo

and ****ed up mayweather(the mexican assassin) in his 7th fight so please stop with all this his record was padded LOOK AT THE RECORDS OF THE PEOPLE HE FOUGHT(we should make a thread about this it would be interesting)

oh yea and i pick PBF and corrales

[Thread Stealer]

u guys are ****ing ridicoulous man LOOK at the records of the people JCC was facing they weren't bums in his third fight he got the vacant WBC super featherweight and by 87 he got the WBA lightweight title maybe to all u guys u don't recognize people but someone who is up on they mexican boxing will recognize edwin"chapo" rosario

ruben castillo

and ****ed up mayweather(the mexican assassin) in his 7th fight so please stop with all this his record was padded LOOK AT THE RECORDS OF THE PEOPLE HE FOUGHT(we should make a thread about this it would be interesting)

oh yea and i pick PBF and corrales

what are you talking about?

chavez had over 40 pro fights when he beat martinez for the vacant 130 lb wbc title, his first belt.

[Fox McCloud]

what are you talking about?

chavez had over 40 pro fights when he beat martinez for the vacant 130 lb wbc title, his first belt.

Guess he didn't realize that there was second page on the boxrec page for Chavez.

[Kc-hoodsta]

Guess he didn't realize that there was second page on the boxrec page for Chavez.

lol


GOT ME

[Fox McCloud]

lol


GOT ME

It's all good, it's been done before. I've done it plenty of times... and then realized I was totally wrong.

[King Koopa]

Mayweather had the more dominating performance
Whitaker fought the better fighter and won (**** that draw BS)