Who's Best 140lb Fighter in History

[ozzienumber1]

****** question really. Kostya Tszyu in his prime could beat them all in the same night.

[Fox McCloud]

No Pernell Whitaker huh?

[Pugilistic™]

julio cesar chavez no doubt

[Fox McCloud]

julio cesar chavez no doubt

That's why I asked why there was no option for Pernell... he made Chavez look bad when they fought.

[-CANE-]

No Pernell Whitaker huh?

Should have read through somebody already said that and I appolagized he should have been in there. I'll try changing it if I can.

[jabsRstiff]

Whitaker beat Chavez up at 147. At 140, he beat Pineda & Brazier (two good foes), & no one else.
He was a great, great fighter who briefly stopped at 140, but didn't do enough there to be considered a great in the division.

[Fox McCloud]

Whitaker beat Chavez up at 147. At 140, he beat Pineda & Brazier (two good foes), & no one else.
He was a great, great fighter who briefly stopped at 140, but didn't do enough there to be considered a great in the division.

****, you are right. I'm going to shut up now... first I asked a repeat question, which was apparantly super incorrect. Ballin.

[oldgringo]

Whitaker beat Chavez up at 147. At 140, he beat Pineda & Brazier (two good foes), & no one else.
He was a great, great fighter who briefly stopped at 140, but didn't do enough there to be considered a great in the division.

i should throw you a beat for talking about my favorite fighter that way.

[jabsRstiff]

More than likely, Whitaker beats anyone who has ever fought at 140.

I wonder what would have happened had Shane Mosley decided to spend some time there ? He was too much in a hurry to get o 147 to face DelaHoya.....when it's very possible that we could have seen the very best of him at 140.

[Contenders]

****!!! I messed up on my vote...meant to vote for JCC, ended up voting for Oscar!