Tougher Fight: Tszyu @ 140... or Delahoya @ 154?

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

I disagree with your opinion that beating Oscar by split decision was a greater acheivement than beating Tszyu by TKO. I think it's pretty darn clear. But, it is an opinion.

...and the majority of people happen to disagree with Hyena's opinion.

No worries.

[THe TRiNiTY]

Yawn......If you want to look at the Phillips fight as your own personal holy grail against Tszyu...then go for it! I see a champion who got up and did what all great champions do...get the belts back. And he did that big time...hall of fame big time.

He came back, great. But you fail to realize that making up for your mistakes isn't an eraser of history, it's a building of the future. So the fight still happened, and he still got beat up pretty badly, against an ordinary fighter.

You rather have a loss to Phillips or anyone that Oscar lost to?

[joepal]

Waaaaaaah.

Haha. Are you running out of material? Cant you find one in the millions of facts that you lovingly collated/collected about Floyd?

[Wiley Hyena]

Very very true.

It's nuthuggery....for you to run to Phillips for cover, and it's hypocritical. First of all, it is reasonably probable that Phillips in 97 would have whipped the crap out of Felix Sturm. If you want to triangulate...triangulate that.

[joepal]

...and the majority of people happen to disagree with Hyena's opinion.

No worries.

Oh thats just below the belt, Dios. Wiley's opinion and your question pertain to two ENTIRELY different things.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Yawn......If you want to look at the Phillips fight as your own personal holy grail against Tszyu...then go for it! I see a champion who got up and did what all great champions do...get the belts back. And he did that big time...hall of fame big time.

a) So, are you saying that when a fighter loses a fight, it is far more important what he does AFTER that loss? ( *makes note of post number*)

b) You may not want to hold your breath on that HoF

[Wiley Hyena]

He came back, great. But you fail to realize that making up for your mistakes isn't an eraser of history, it's a building of the future. So the fight still happened, and he still got beat up pretty badly, against an ordinary fighter.

You rather have a loss to Phillips or anyone that Oscar lost to?

I'm sorry you're not making sense. Tszyu unified the belts and became a lock for the HOF after the Phillips fight. Which Tszyu do you want to see here? I believe we're talking about Tszyu in 2005.

[joepal]

It's nuthuggery....for you to run to Phillips for cover, and it's hypocritical. First of all, it is reasonably probable that Phillips in 97 would have whipped the crap out of Felix Sturm. If you want to triangulate...triangulate that.

The ironic thing is, which he vigorously denies by the way, is how he presents himself to be an objective poster WHEN ALL HIS COTDAMN POSTS ARE SO PARTISAN TO FLOYD, and EVEN ACTUALLY AGREEING WITH DIOS ALL THE TIME.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Oh thats just below the belt, Dios. Wiley's opinion and your question pertain to two ENTIRELY different things.

A JWW ( which PBF and RH both essentially are) has two options:

36 yr old Tszyu @ 140 or 34 yr old DLH @ 154

Which is the tougher fight?

This is such a straightforward concept. Nothing tricky here.

[joepal]

a) So, are you saying that when a fighter loses a fight, it is far more important what he does AFTER that loss? ( *makes note of post number*)

b) You may not want to hold your breath on that HoF

Hey! Are you ducking my question like Floyd ducks elite competition?