Mayweather's best win at 140?

[Left Hook Tua]

On paper, it seems like Gatti is the better win... more times being a world champion, for a belt, etc.

But I was thinking, DeMarcus Corley seems to be a pretty solid fighter, who has never quite been able to break through, but he is still a good fighter. He is a former world champion at 140.

SO... who do you all think is the better win for Mayweather at 140?

can we do a poll on his best win at 154?

[Fox McCloud]

can we do a poll on his best win at 154?

I have a feeling it will be a unanimous decision (which he also should have gotten in his best win at 154).

[Left Hook Tua]

I have a feeling it will be a unanimous decision (which he also should have gotten in his best win at 154).

i bet you oscar wouldn't even get the most votes.

[Jim Jeffries]

Gatti was the bigger name, but I think his best days were 8 years earlier and two weight classes down. Corley was a better fighter at 140.

[machotime]

What logical boxing fan thought that Gatti would have a chance??

[Scott9945]

Mosley is a CHEATER. I have no respect for people that do steroids to gain a competitive advantage.

Not meaning to sound smug, but you are only aware of a small fraction of the fighters you have seen who were using illegal supplements.

[Clegg]

Man, you hate Mayweather even more than I do. I don't actually hate Floyd, I just dislike him and I hate his obnoxious personality and hit and run style, but I will admit it is very effective for him. If Floyd fought more like one of my boys Shane Mosley than I would respect him more because Mosley is a real warrior and he is not afraid to go toe to toe. I think Mosley is also gonna go toe toe with the so called unstoppable Miguel Cotto and KO/TKO him in the later rounds. I am still sticking to my prediction that Hatton will upset Mayweather and KO him with a bodyshot in the late rounds.

I was reading this and was like "Wow, is that how Wlad Owns used to post back then?"

And then I read the next comment

You must hate Holyfield and Fat Toney as well.

and realised...no.

[withoutthee88]

LOL, good call on May-Hatton, Wlad.

[mspiegelo]

gatti was a much easier victory, no question. he had nothing left. gatti boosted pbf's profile way more though b/c of his name recognition....

[Silencers]

Definitely Gatti.