Yahoo! Introduces It's Top 10 P4P

[tredh]

And why is that?

Because of all the crying and complaining some of yall doing about Hattons place on the list.

[Bogler]

cotto too high. where's hatton? vazquez not yet, but prbbly knocking on the door.

[!! Mr. Soprano]

Because of all the crying and complaining some of yall doing about Hattons place on the list.

It's not crying and complaining, it's called disagreeing and discussing the list.

Wouldn't you "***** and complain" is Mayweather was not #1, but lets say 3rd?

[ROSEWOOD]

It's not crying and complaining, it's called disagreeing and discussing the list.

Wouldn't you "***** and complain" is Mayweather was not #1, but lets say 3rd?

I would....lol

Hatton should indeed be on the list. I'm talking like top 5 maybe...Maybe Wald as well...I truely believe Sugar Shane should have been left off the list.

[!! Mr. Soprano]

calzage has beat no one good in his career and they have him 3?? what a joke!!! hatton should be somewhere in the top 10. he has beaten 2 great legends close to there primes. he will defeintely be in the top 10 when he beats maywather.

One of the reasons we don't know much about Calzaghe's opponents is because he has been ruling the division for a decade and most of the big and loud fights have been happening at either Middleweight (Hopkins) or Light Heavy (RJJ), while the British Calzaghe was kept out of the US media.

Just look at the fighters at Super Middleweight.. recognize any big names (except for Lacy and Kessler of course) The US networks were just never inetrested in that weight class (That is until Lacy emerged) and after Calzaghe shot him down (shooled him) only then he made some noise in US

Shall he beat Kessler, that will make him an undefeated unified champion with, what 22 title defenses?
3rd place, and rightfully so. - but not until he beats Kessler.

[MightyMikeA]

What's laughable is you think Manferdo Jr is his second best victory. Only know American fighters, huh?

I never said that. In boxing's lb4lb rankings it's more of like a "what have you done for me lately" criteria that bares the most emphasis. Of course I know Calzaghe whipped up on a bored Eubanks about a decade ago and of course he's beaten the Byron Mitchell's and Evans Ashira's of the world. But can you honestly say that the following past six fights of his warrants a number 3 ranking or even a top 10 ranking for that matter;

Peter Manfredo Jr.-sucks and shouldn't even be anywhere near 168.
Sakio Bika-crude and just lost to Lucian Bute (also gave Joe trouble)
Jeff Lacy-even without a messed up rotator cup, Tsypko should've won
Evans Ashira-who cares
Mario Veit-who cares
Kabary Salem-who cares

C'mon, besides Lacy (whom we now know sucks and can't box for ****) that reads like a whose who clown's list.

And you know something else? People are placing all this stock in a win over Kessler. Kessler is good, but nowhere near great. If he does beat Kessler, then he should get into the top-ten based on his total dominance in a division (even though it's not a very good one), but he still won't be remembered as a great fighter.

[tredh]

It's not crying and complaining, it's called disagreeing and discussing the list.

Wouldn't you "***** and complain" is Mayweather was not #1, but lets say 3rd?

Actually I wouldn't ***** and complain because that would be that person's opinion which they are entitled to and I would also disagree with big difference than some of the **** you Hatton fans are saying.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Yahoo LOL!

Look at the people that did the rankings.
Plus, Kevin Iole doesn't have credibility with you??

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

After Hatton dismissed two legends - Tszyu and Castillo

If Castillo was a legend when Hatton beat him, what was he when Floyd beat him?

[jamesbrown]

Kevin Iole is an idiot this guy had Margarito beating Williams.

hahaha the fight was hard to call right???