De La Hoya/Mayweather was closer then Castillo/Mayweather

[OptimusWolf]

Yea, I think Mayweather eeked out the Castillo decision and he schooled Dela Hoya.

See what i mean about some mayweather fans - that fight was nowhere near a schooling. watch winky-tito or calzaghe lacy for a schooling.

[dino]

as i said in previous post, its been proven from my predictions in the past as well as many other things that i know my ****!

most of you idiots said jirov was robbed vs mesi, when jirov took a beating for 8 rounds and mesi was dropped in the 9 and 10 and most of you claim it was a robbery

hopkins rarely threw punches the first 7 rounds vs taylor but the most of you said hopkins was robbed

hatton dominated collazo early on in the fight and dropped him once, collazo had a few stronger later rounds as hatton declined in the fight, but he still didnt win enough to win the fight and you trolls said collazo was robbed

being that most of you can't judge fights, let me explain to you as quick as i can how to judge fights, all fights are different...you judge fights ROUND BY ROUND, not who looked good at the end of the fight, a round is 3 minutes, you give the round to the guy who landed the most effective shots or the most shots in the round....not a guy who loses 2:30 of a round then trys to rough a guy up for 20 seconds (tarver-jones 1..castillo-mayweather 1).

de la hoya had mayweather up against the ropes and was throwing shots the WHOLE ROUND...castillo tried that in the LATER PART OF THE FIGHT after mayweather hurt his hands....IF A FIGHT IS 12 ROUNDS AND YOU LOSE THE FIRST 7 OR 8 YOU CANT WIN! UNLESS YOU KNOCK THE GUY OUT! it dosent matter what you do in the last 3 or 4 rounds, and thats what most of you dont understand

anytime you take a forum full of people who say dempsey and marciano would knock klitchko or lewis out, you all really cant be taken seriously...its a hand full of people who actually have common sense on this forum and i mean a hand full!..like 4 or 5 out of 100, asian sensation (sometimes) and a few other guys

[tredh]

See what i mean about some mayweather fans - that fight was nowhere near a schooling. watch winky-tito or calzaghe lacy for a schooling.

I agree that PBF didn't school De la Hoya but he clearly won like a 116-112 scorecard says which you had. The thing I disagree with you about is De la Hoya has never been a 12 round fighter. He has had stamina problems his whole career.

[GunStar]

See what i mean about some mayweather fans - that fight was nowhere near a schooling. watch winky-tito or calzaghe lacy for a schooling.

It was pretty close to schooling, Floyd won his 8 rounds pretty clearly and Oscar did not won his 4 rounds clearly like the way Floyd did.

[sonofisis]

See what i mean about some mayweather fans - that fight was nowhere near a schooling. watch winky-tito or calzaghe lacy for a schooling.

No need to nit-pick over words, it is relative. Ok, he did not literally "school" him in that way, no, but he beat him soundly, which is what I meant..

[-Hyperion-]

Shut up, you had Stinky winning against Bitchnard.

you had taylor over winky
also pbf over castillo :*******:

oh and you need to see winky vs bitchnard again man, and put real attention to what theyre doing and how bitchnard jsut flurries while landing nothing..

[sonofisis]

also pbf over castillo :*******:

This can be argued! Some of you bitches on here act like Castillo beat him up or something and Floyd just got molly wopped, obviously he did enough in the opinion of the judges and won by a wider point margin then, than in the next fight, where he won more convincingly.

[-Hyperion-]

This can be argued! Some of you bitches on here act like Castillo beat him up or something and Floyd just got molly wopped, obviously he did enough in the opinion of the judges and won by a wider point margin then, than in the next fight, where he won more convincingly.

so what just cus he won the rematch then he is forgiven of having robbed the first fight???

i tell you this, i was a huge pbf fan and i was kind of caught in the hype and thought he was one of the best after seeing his 140 fights, as i was a new boxing fan in 2005.

i looked up his fights that i hadnt seen and i ran into jlc vs pbf 1 and i though castillo won 115-111...and iwas like wtf happened, well floyd was injured, then i see the rematch and while floyd won close but very clearly, he had to work so ****ing hard to win those fights against a fighter he should have oblitarated with his speed, but the truth is floyd isnt as fats as some guys make him out to be jlc knew how to cut the ring and took his foot speed(which imo is the only great speed he has), and pbf was done, his hand speed is only explosive above 130 but he isnt fast at putting combinations together and stuff,thats when it hit me he was no better than say de la hoya, shane, hopkins, winky and those guys, hes one of the elite but no one to compare with say james toney, roy jones armstrong, robinson, ali, leonard...and i wouldnt have a problem with it if it wasnt for pbf saying he is the best ever.....

[GunStar]

you had taylor over winky
also pbf over castillo :*******:

oh and you need to see winky vs bitchnard again man, and put real attention to what theyre doing and how bitchnard jsut flurries while landing nothing..

Yea I had Taylor winning his fight but I don't have a problem with someone scoring it for Stinky, I think Stinky did the best against Taylor.

I can't agree with you with Stinky over Bitchnard or Castaco over Gayweather, I think both Bitchnard and Gayweather clearly won their fights, yea most of the rounds were pretty close in both fights, but It was pretty easy to see who was in control of those 2 fights, it was Bitchnard and Gayweather.

[Winkyftw!]

as i said in previous post, its been proven from my predictions in the past as well as many other things that i know my ****!

most of you idiots said jirov was robbed vs mesi, when jirov took a beating for 8 rounds and mesi was dropped in the 9 and 10 and most of you claim it was a robbery

hopkins rarely threw punches the first 7 rounds vs taylor but the most of you said hopkins was robbed

hatton dominated collazo early on in the fight and dropped him once, collazo had a few stronger later rounds as hatton declined in the fight, but he still didnt win enough to win the fight and you trolls said collazo was robbed

being that most of you can't judge fights, let me explain to you as quick as i can how to judge fights, all fights are different...you judge fights ROUND BY ROUND, not who looked good at the end of the fight, a round is 3 minutes, you give the round to the guy who landed the most effective shots or the most shots in the round....not a guy who loses 2:30 of a round then trys to rough a guy up for 20 seconds (tarver-jones 1..castillo-mayweather 1).

de la hoya had mayweather up against the ropes and was throwing shots the WHOLE ROUND...castillo tried that in the LATER PART OF THE FIGHT after mayweather hurt his hands....IF A FIGHT IS 12 ROUNDS AND YOU LOSE THE FIRST 7 OR 8 YOU CANT WIN! UNLESS YOU KNOCK THE GUY OUT! it dosent matter what you do in the last 3 or 4 rounds, and thats what most of you dont understand

anytime you take a forum full of people who say dempsey and marciano would knock klitchko or lewis out, you all really cant be taken seriously...its a hand full of people who actually have common sense on this forum and i mean a hand full!..like 4 or 5 out of 100, asian sensation (sometimes) and a few other guys

LMFAO...

De La HOya was the one losing the first 230 of the round and throwing punches in bunches at the end.

He didn't throw punches the hwole round, he had 10 second spurt of blocked shots. He may have thrown more punches than Mayweather, but he was clearly out landed, and out skilled.

Watch the fight again, and don't let the crowd bias you. ****.