Where are all the "Gatti for the Hall of Fame" people now?

[TheEvilSaint]

His resume.

Results.

thats just looking at black and white. like i said, ur just nitpicking.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

he shouldnt be in the HOF based on their standards and his record and certain performances. but dont call the man a scrub dude, thats not right. the man was ALL heart and when he was in the ring u knew it was gonna be a good fight, so dont dis him by callin him a scrub. he wont be in the HOF, but he will be remembered.

Losses to Manfredy, Robinson 2x, Ward, Baldomir and Gomez?

Losses to Mayweather and Delahoya are clearly understandable.

Wins over... Who again?

[SpeedKillz]

Losses to Manfredy, Robinson 2x, Ward, Baldomir and Gomez?

Losses to Mayweather and Delahoya are clearly understandable.

Wins over... Who again?

i aint sayin he's the greatest fighter or even an A fighter. i even said he shouldnt be in the HOF, but he aint no scrub. he was a tough ass fighter with no quit in his mind no matter how hurt or bloodied up. he aint no scrub. he fought til he possibly couldnt. and the losse to bald and gomez are clearly after he was past bein SHOT...

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

thats just looking at black and white. like i said, ur just nitpicking.

Looking at the results of athletic competition is "nitpicking"? I respectfully disagree.

[TheEvilSaint]

Looking at the results of athletic competition is "nitpicking"? I respectfully disagree.

well saying "he beat nobody, hes a scrub who doesnt belong in the HOF" is indeed nitpicking. by that criteria you have to have a well-stocked resume to get in and there are plenty of HOFers who do not meet that criteria. seriously, look at some of the resumes of a few of those HOFers. there are a few that are quite unimpressive.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

this is the one i meant

I guess I'm an internet warrior who feels qualifies to call a fighter "average". Even one who has displayed as much heart or guts as Gatti has.
(Except in the Mayweather fight where he stopped letting his hands go by round 2)

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

well saying "he beat nobody, hes a scrub who doesnt belong in the HOF" is indeed nitpicking. by that criteria you have to have a well-stocked resume to get in and there are plenty of HOFers who do not meet that criteria. seriously, look at some of the resumes of a few of those HOFers. there are a few that are quite unimpressive.

Actually, you will have a HARD time finding a HoFer who hasn't beaten another HopFer... or at least was VERY competitive with them.

You're welcome to prove me wrong.

[TheEvilSaint]

Actually, you will have a HARD time finding a HoFer who hasn't beaten another HopFer... or at least was VERY competitive with them.

You're welcome to prove me wrong.

and for that reason gatti shouldnt be allowed in?

pipino cuevas didnt beat or wasnt competative with any HOFers.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

i aint sayin he's the greatest fighter or even an A fighter. i even said he shouldnt be in the HOF, but he aint no scrub. he was a tough ass fighter with no quit in his mind no matter how hurt or bloodied up. he aint no scrub. he fought til he possibly couldnt. and the losse to bald and gomez are clearly after he was past bein SHOT...

OK. Let's say that you consider the Mosleys, Delahoyas and Mayweather's as A fighters....agreed?

And the Castillo's, Corrales', Judahs are B+/A- fighters.

And the Manfredys are B fighters.


WHAT WOULD YOU CONSIDER GATTI TO BE?

[SpeedKillz]

OK. Let's say that you consider the Mosleys, Delahoyas and Mayweather's as A fighters....agreed?

And the Castillo's, Corrales', Judahs are B+/A- fighters.

And the Manfredys are B fighters.


WHAT WOULD YOU CONSIDER GATTI TO BE?

a C fighter, which is what floyd called gatti, and which is how gatti fought against top opposition. i aint arguin that. i am sayin that u cant call him a scrub cuz he ALWAYS gave it his all, even when he was clearly outclassed, he never wanted to give up... i think that is worthy enough of not bein called a scrub, not HOF worthy, but worthy enough for respect, no?