How did you score Magarito vs Williams

[trips420]

I had it 7-5 Williams but i could understand 8-4 but i thought Williams won it.Williams fought smart and stayed on the outside and tied up Tony on the inside.I picked Tony to win but i based that on the fact that i figured he would give up his reach and fight on the inside like he always does.By the time Tony put in enough body work to slow him down a bit where he could get inside of that freakish reach Williams had won to many rounds.

[wolfgang]

Williams is my favorite fighter and I thought he won the first 7 rounds, but after I rewatched the fight, I thought it was much closer.

[Bambicolors]

round 1 Williams 10 - 9
Round 2 Williams 10 - 9
ROund 3 Williams 10 - 9
Qound 4 MArgarito 9 - 10
ROund 5 Williams 10 - 9
Round 6 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 7 MArgarito 9 - 10
ROund 8 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 9 Williams 10 - 9
ROund 10 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 11 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 12 Williams 10 - 9

That round 12 damn!!

I hope Cotto fight MArgarito, Cotto will get knocked out.

[Living Legend]

7 rounds Williams 4 rounds Margarito 1 rd even... anything other than that is plain ridiculous... I swear fight fans decide who should have won on the would of could of's instead what actually happened... Which was Margarito getting soundly "outboxed" for the first 6 and half to seven straight rounds... not "out heighted" not "out ran" but "out boxed"...

[Living Legend]

round 1 Williams 10 - 9
Round 2 Williams 10 - 9
ROund 3 Williams 10 - 9
Qound 4 MArgarito 9 - 10
ROund 5 Williams 10 - 9
Round 6 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 7 MArgarito 9 - 10
ROund 8 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 9 Williams 10 - 9
ROund 10 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 11 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 12 Williams 10 - 9

That round 12 damn!!

I hope Cotto fight MArgarito, Cotto will get knocked out.

Man you have got to be on drugs, by the way you have it, the fight was a draw!!! What fight were you watching? and what about that fight would lead yo crazy ass to believe Margarito won and would knock cotto out... Margarito is coming close to the end of his career bruh... Cotto, Hatton, Mayweather, Mosley and Collazo would beat Margarito rigth now, with Hatton and Cotton knocking Margarito out...

[GooGoo]

9 rounds Williams
3 rounds Margarito

[niceguy45]

round 1 Williams 10 - 9
Round 2 Williams 10 - 9
ROund 3 Williams 10 - 9
Qound 4 MArgarito 9 - 10
ROund 5 Williams 10 - 9
Round 6 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 7 MArgarito 9 - 10
ROund 8 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 9 Williams 10 - 9
ROund 10 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 11 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 12 Williams 10 - 9

That round 12 damn!!

I hope Cotto fight MArgarito, Cotto will get knocked out.

that;s exactly how i had watching it the 2nd time

[nozorok]

round 1 Williams 10 - 9
Round 2 Williams 10 - 9
ROund 3 Williams 10 - 9
Qound 4 MArgarito 9 - 10
ROund 5 Williams 10 - 9
Round 6 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 7 MArgarito 9 - 10
ROund 8 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 9 Williams 10 - 9
ROund 10 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 11 MArgarito 9 - 10
Round 12 Williams 10 - 9

That round 12 damn!!

I hope Cotto fight MArgarito, Cotto will get knocked out.

Strangely, I had the exact same scores. Go figure.

[ßringer]

I don't think anybody who watched the fight only once is at liberty to judge really. When I first saw the fight I had it 8 rounds to 4 for Williams but going back the second and third time there were a lot of rounds that could've gone either way. And I think one must watch the fight multiple times in order to make an accurate judgment.

Anyway, after watching the fight 3 times I had the fight 7 rounds to 5 for Williams. With Margarito winning the 6th, 7th, 8th, 10th and 11th rounds. But really the 6th round was so close it's hard to say. Williams certainly threw a lot and I know throwing impresses judges but he rarely connected anything solid.

I think that no matter how we scored it we can all agree that there were some very close rounds in this one.

[wolfgang]

I had it like that, but scored round 4 to williams, he won that round easy, maybe the 6 round even, but still had it 115-113, and thats the closes it could be.