Jermain Taylor is P4P #1 on my list

[jack_the_rippuh]

He's not better than the rest of the fighters on the list.
Talent does play a part in P4P rankings.

Calling him P4P #1 means that you think he's the best fighter in boxing (if weight isn't a factor).

That's just false.
100% false.

[GunStar]

He's not better than the rest of the fighters on the list.
Talent does play a part in P4P rankings.

Calling him P4P #1 means that you think he's the best fighter in boxing (if weight isn't a factor).

That's just false.
100% false.

If you go by talent then guys like Pac, Rafa, Hatton etc... does not belong on the list.

[jack_the_rippuh]

If you go by talent then guys like Pac, Rafa, Hatton etc... does not belong on the list.

Why not?
They're talented at using their advantages.

[GunStar]

Why not?
They're talented at using their advantages.

Taylor is more skilled then all 3, you just failed!

[Tysonisgod]

is pound for pound not ment to be judging the fighters skill level against anothers skill level if there was no weight to think about?

[Tysonisgod]

Floyd mayweather p4p no question's asked like ive said since day one

[GunStar]

Floyd mayweather p4p no question's asked like ive said since day one

I agree that PBF is P4P #1, but he said on Jay Leno he's retied now, so we can have him on the P4P list anymore if he's retired.

[Steelhammer86]

Good Defense

You're doing a good job of defending your fighter Taylor here, Gunstar1. After his performance Saturday night, your starting this thread shows you have balls.

[GunStar]

You're doing a good job of defending your fighter Taylor here, Gunstar1. After his performance Saturday night, you're starting this thread shows you have balls.

Thank you sir!

[-Antonio-]

I thought Winky beat Taylor so I have him higher. Rafael Marquez has done more imo.