Is Jose Luis Castillo in Your Top 10 P4P?

[OptimusWolf]

I honestly don't believe 8 people don't have him in their top twenty.

he was 8-10 before his dodgy win against Ngoudjo, so you could see him slipping out of the top 10, but out of the top 20 without being inactive or losing??

Just shows you
a)what p4p lists are inevitably like
b)how some people in NSB have little to know background knowledge and judge on the latest info only.

[squealpiggy]

What does this topic have to do with Hatton? You're paranoid...

Just about every topic you start has something to do with Hatton! Sure, I honestly can't see how a topic about Hatton's next opponent is related to Hatton.

[RAESAAD]

Just outside for me I'd say 12 range.....but I don't sit around and keep and update my own P4P list either......

[Ramamaiden]

Just about every topic you start has something to do with Hatton! Sure, I honestly can't see how a topic about Hatton's next opponent is related to Hatton.

hahahahhaha....




btw castillo is a great fighter, but seeing his last fight i wouldnt even put him in the top 25.
i hope against hatton he makes a good fight like the ones he used to do.

[Parody]

And Mayweathers win against a NON rated ODLH was Impressive???

I am sorry But the hypocracy is astounding...

1. How can you compare Mayweather vs Dela Hoya, the biggest fight ever in boxing against Castillo vs Reyes or Castillo vs Ngoudjo?

2. ODLH was in the top 5, Reyes and Ngoudjo werent

3. How did this turn into a Mayweather thread?

[yrrej]

I might put him in the top 10 based on the fact that there are so few decent fighters right now, and many contenders have lost or looked poorly lately. Anyway, Castillo looks like he is going to be the next Yori Boy Campa, hanging around and beating fringe contenders long after he should have retired.....

[Easy-E]

Both Agave and EliteSoldier are mindless nuthuggers.
JLC has no place in the top 5.
******s.

[Easy-E]

And Mayweathers win against a NON rated ODLH was Impressive???

I am sorry But the hypocracy is astounding...

welter man you should stay in the lounge.
when you talk about boxing well....

[RAESAAD]

welter man you should stay in the lounge.
when you talk about boxing well....

but also

[{BrownBomber}]

I might put him in the top 10 based on the fact that there are so few decent fighters right now, and many contenders have lost or looked poorly lately. Anyway, Castillo looks like he is going to be the next Yori Boy Campa, hanging around and beating fringe contenders long after he should have retired.....

Castillo has been very competitive at the elite level something Campas never did. "So few decent fighters" Ya if your watching the heavyweight division.

By the way Campas still fights because he never made any money.