Is Jose Luis Castillo in Your Top 10 P4P?

[me2007]

i think his victory over Mayweather means he's top 10 at least

[Welter_Skelter]

A year ago I would've had Castillo in the top 10 but now I have him in the top 15, his last 2 wins have not been very impressive against guys like Rolando Reyes & Herman Ngoudjo.

And Mayweathers win against a NON rated ODLH was Impressive???

I am sorry But the hypocracy is astounding...

[spinksjinx]

i think his victory over Mayweather means he's top 10 at least

Last time I checked that wasnt in the record books. No matter how many times the people dispute the decision doesnt make it right...

Castillo falls short every time he gets his big chance and Castillo for the most part is in fights that are snoozers...Relying on your opponent to make you have a good fight does not make you a top p4p fighter...Sure it takes two to tango, but it only takes one to dominate and Castillo is lackluster 8 times out of 10.

[ROSEWOOD]

One win over Chico doesn't mean jack....He maybe top 50 but not my top 20..

[Technical_Skill]

Ermm sorta, he doesnt make my ten either, but if Hatton beats him its a big thing and hatton deserves credit, no question about it, at the end of the day at least he is fighting someone proper, and gave up his IBF belt not to fight some bum.

[GunStar]

And Mayweathers win against a NON rated ODLH was Impressive???

I am sorry But the hypocracy is astounding...

Lol, are you comparing Delahoya to guys like Rolando Reyes & Herman Ngoudjo.

Mayweather was my P4P #1 guy many years ago, even when Ring magazine at Hopkins at #1 and Floyd at #2, my #1 was Floyd.

[tito yuca]

Reyes was because Corrales fell thru and Herman was his first fight at 140.Not easy fights as some might think. I'll admit they both where horrible fights for him but the better the fighter he faces the better his performances are.

Dude, his first fight at 140 was in 2001 and he's fought at 147 several times.

[.Mik.]

This is another anti-Hatton topic. $in waits until people vote that Castillo isn't a p4p fighter and then uses it as ammunition to disparage Hatton as and when he beats Castillo.

Doesnt work though because most of the people have voted Castillo between 10-15 P4P. So if Hatton beats him, he'll be one of the few people in the top 10 P4P list who have beaten 2 people within the top 15 P4P fighters. So really...Hatton should leapfrog anyone else who hasnt.

[Guest]

Doesnt work though because most of the people have voted Castillo between 10-15 P4P. So if Hatton beats him, he'll be one of the few people in the top 10 P4P list who have beaten 2 people within the top 15 P4P fighters. So really...Hatton should leapfrog anyone else who hasnt.

What does this topic have to do with Hatton? You're paranoid...

[.Mik.]

I wasnt responding to the topic though, was I?

I was responding to the person who mentioned Hatton. Hence why I quoted him.