Is Jose Luis Castillo in Your Top 10 P4P?

[Guest]

Where do you rank Castillo in your P4P list?

[Derranged_]

Where do you rank Castillo in your P4P list?

You little 'thread whore;' how many threads are you gonna create before you get banned you damn spammer!

[spinksjinx]

No and he shouldnt be in anybodies he hasnt done anything worth a squat to be considered anymore than a top 10 contender...I leave the p4p rankings to the champions...The guy is inconsistent and struggles with a lot of fighters...

[Mozza]

He doesn't make my P4P top 10 and I don't understand why Hatton keeps saying this fight is a chance for him to beat someone else who is above him in the P4P ratings.

[{BrownBomber}]

P4P he should be top 10. For a while he had a streak of great wins. He has never been out classed by anyone and that includes #1 on that list. Sure he has had bad nights but he is a nightmare for any type fighter.
P4P as in if they where all the same weight....who would win?
He makes top ten easy.

[GunStar]

A year ago I would've had Castillo in the top 10 but now I have him in the top 15, his last 2 wins have not been very impressive against guys like Rolando Reyes & Herman Ngoudjo.

[{BrownBomber}]

A year ago I would've had Castillo in the top 10 but now I have him in the top 15, his last 2 wins have not been very impressive against guys like Rolando Reyes & Herman Ngoudjo.

Reyes was because Corrales fell thru and Herman was his first fight at 140.Not easy fights as some might think. I'll admit they both where horrible fights for him but the better the fighter he faces the better his performances are.

[GunStar]

Reyes was because Corrales fell thru and Herman was his first fight at 140.Not easy fights as some might think. I'll admit they both where horrible fights for him but the better the fighter he faces the better his performances are.

If he KO's Hatton like I think he will, then I will have him around 6 or 7, I think he's not the same fighter anymore, he's had too many fights and his first fight with Chico made both Castillo and Chico old!

[iluvboxing.com]

No and he shouldnt be in anybodies he hasnt done anything worth a squat to be considered anymore than a top 10 contender...I leave the p4p rankings to the champions...The guy is inconsistent and struggles with a lot of fighters...

and i hope corey spinks is some kin to you

[iluvboxing.com]

A year ago I would've had Castillo in the top 10 but now I have him in the top 15, his last 2 wins have not been very impressive against guys like Rolando Reyes & Herman Ngoudjo.

didnt see the fight w herman ngoudjo but he outclassed the hell out of reyes and i liked reyes(as a prospect not over jlc)