Let's Settle the Debate: Who Won Mayweather-Castillo I?

[J Mac]

This is a bit pointless as it is just gonna start a long and boring argument between Floyd haters/fans. At the end of the day Floyd is the better fighter, but he lost the first fight. He showed that it was a blip by dominating the 2nd fight, so for the haters ur right he lost, for his supporters yeah he lost but put that down to a bad night at the office. He got a gift but i can't actually think of a top fighter who didn't get a gift decision!

[El Jesus]

goonie gu guu.....

haha, thats how you know brown bomber is down with the black folks referencing that ****.

[GunStar]

I'm a little confuesed to why people think Floyd lost the first fight and dominated the first fight.

I had Floyd winning 8 rounds in the first fight and 9 in the second fight, very similar scores, I don't see why people say that he lost the first fight and dominated the second, this does not make any sense to me at all!

[El Jesus]

I'm a little confuesed to why people think Floyd lost the first fight and dominated the first fight.

I had Floyd winning 8 rounds in the first fight and 9 in the second fight, very similar scores, I don't see why people say that he lost the first fight and dominated the second, this does not make any sense to me at all!

one thing i will say is that the alot of the counted punches that castillo landed not all of them were exactly flush punches. Castillo landed alot around his shoulders/arms in the first fight. The fact is, if your in a football game and your down by 28-7 but you rally the score to 28-27 when time runs out, you still ****ing lose the game 28-27. If you score round by round on this fight, Floyd wins the majority of the early rounds, to say floyd lost would mean that Castillo won rounds 6-12 and yall know that **** aint true, especially in the 11th when floyd went toe to toe and didnt just back down. alot of you havent seen the ****ing fight.

[GunStar]

one thing i will say is that the alot of the counted punches that castillo landed not all of them were exactly flush punches. Castillo landed alot around his shoulders/arms in the first fight. The fact is, if your in a football game and your down by 28-7 but you rally the score to 28-27 when time runs out, you still ****ing lose the game 28-27. If you score round by round on this fight, Floyd wins the majority of the early rounds, to say floyd lost would mean that Castillo won rounds 6-12 and yall know that **** aint true, especially in the 11th when floyd went toe to toe and didnt just back down. alot of you havent seen the ****ing fight.

Good post! I'm not a big believer in Compubox, it's done by people, it's always flawed, you know when a boxer is holding and punching, all of that counts as punches landed.

[Joartcc3]

Between the arguments presented by blind PBF fans and data from compubox on punch thrown and the huge discrepancy on power punches, your arguments mean nothing.

Castillo won. PBf's face clearly shows the face of a beaten man and data clearly shows he lost.

Ran like a chicken, threw about 30 punches per round and connected far less. Only dumbs will give rounds to boxers like that.

[The Troll]

Mayweather won but it was a close fight, I havn't seen it in a while but I think I scored it 7 rounds to 5.

[cortdawg25]

That is the most REDICULOUS score i have ever heard.

Nobody on here knows how to score a fight. FLoyd did NOTHING to win, he got his ass beat up that fight.

It doesnt effect his career though, it only enhances it because he avenged it easily.

I had Castillo winning by 2 rounds minimum, and there is no way it could be any closer. end of story

I don't understand how you can have Castillo winning by 2 rounds when Floyd had won the 1st five rounds. Are you saying Castillo won 7 rds straight against Floyd? It was a easy fight for him until the cortizone started wearing off.

[cortdawg25]

one thing i will say is that the alot of the counted punches that castillo landed not all of them were exactly flush punches. Castillo landed alot around his shoulders/arms in the first fight. The fact is, if your in a football game and your down by 28-7 but you rally the score to 28-27 when time runs out, you still ****ing lose the game 28-27. If you score round by round on this fight, Floyd wins the majority of the early rounds, to say floyd lost would mean that Castillo won rounds 6-12 and yall know that **** aint true, especially in the 11th when floyd went toe to toe and didnt just back down. alot of you havent seen the ****ing fight.

exactly. Floyd was winning easy in the early rds and after rd 5 the fight started to change some in Castillo favor.

[Guest]

exactly. Floyd was winning easy in the early rds and after rd 5 the fight started to change some in Castillo favor.

Exactly. The best I could see it is a draw for Castillo. I just don't see any way he won that fight...