New controversial Ring P4P ranking

[Easy-E]

I kinda like the list but im not so sure.

Mine is probably
Floyd
Pac
Winky
Rafa
Taylor
JMM
Hops
Joe C
MAB
Mosley

[bishop2006]

WDF is Hatton doin in there? Because he beat Urango? Im glad the Marquez bros are in there

[Shanus]

Having JMM in the top 5 is ridiculous, top 10, MAYBE, but 5 after beating an older version of Barrera? That's just dumb.

[CaLLaHaN]

Winky's first real fighter at 160 handed him a draw. He then went back to fighting the 154 dropouts. He preys on smaller fighters.

that argument makes no sense when winky is moving past middleweight right now to fight bhop...

[niceguy45]

Well, the less pounds you are, the higher on a P4P you get

Does anyone think Cotto should now be in the top 10?

nah not yet maybe after 3 more fights judah, mosley, margarito or even mayweather win or lose

[Gareth Ivanovic]

Having JMM in the top 5 is ridiculous, top 10, MAYBE, but 5 after beating an older version of Barrera? That's just dumb.

Yeah Barrera is older, but he still is a great fighter and JMM IMO beat him without a doubt. JMM has been a great fighter for a long time, but not had that huge name on his resume until now. He had a chance at Hamed, but Hamed ducked him on the advice of Steward. Because Steward knew that JMM would give Hamed a lesson. Also his management hasn't made the best decisions for him.

Also why do certain people think the lower weights are overrated. The lower weights you get to see boxing at its best. They have speed, fast hands, heart, determination, and power (maybe not the one punch power that the higher weights do). I am not saying the higher weights don't have this, but more respect needs to be showed for lower weights.

[The Raging Bull]

He had a chance at Hamed, but Hamed ducked him on the advice of Steward. Because Steward knew that JMM would give Hamed a lesson.

No, he ducked Hamed.

This is from Boxrec encyclopedia.

To Hamed's credit, he did offer Marquez a fight in the summer of 2000, but Marquez declined. Marquez did end up getting a title shot against Freddie Norwood.

And I agree that JMM shouldn't be in the top 5 P4P, I'd have him around 7. Winky should be higher.

[Gareth Ivanovic]

On the countdown to Barrera-Marquez thats what Steward said.

[Gareth Ivanovic]

Yeah i think your right Hamed ducked him for awhile then finally gave him a shot, but Marquez declined which gave the opportunity to Barrera.

[The Raging Bull]

On the countdown to Barrera-Marquez thats what Steward said.

Oh, well that's what it say's on the Boxrec Encyclopedia