PBF.. whos the best he beat??

[Sin City]

This is sweet 3 pages of a Mayweather thread with no flaming or arguing... If NSB was always like this and people weren't so ****** we would have more posters and alot of more good discussions... To bad we get alot of A Holes coming through this site.

[Nacho_Analstain]

This is sweet 3 pages of a Mayweather thread with no flaming or arguing... If NSB was always like this and people weren't so ****** we would have more posters and alot of more good discussions... To bad we get alot of A Holes coming through this site.

i agree,a good clean boxing convo,cant beat it

[Nacho_Analstain]

it would be better sat round a big table with a buffet and free beer though

[Sin City]

i agree,a good clean boxing convo,cant beat it

It also encourages people who are not boxing scholars or new to the sport to post.. **** like HAHA FCKN n00b PWN!! makes you not wanna post sometimes... I am a casual fan and know my ins and outs know most the boxers and some history.. I learn a little more everyday by watching more fights reading up on more fighters and having discussions like these.. Sometimes people have an inferiority complex and wanna act like they know everything about everything putting other dudes down for whatever reason..
My bad getting off topic...lol Just got back from Psychology not to long ago lol ....Back to the subject!!

[Sin City]

it would be better sat round a big table with a buffet and free beer though

Damn right!...

[ThaHorseman]

His best opposition was in the Lightweight devision..
Jesus Chavez
Jose Luis Castillo
Diego Corrales
those are the main ones I can think of..
As a Lightweight I give him credit but when he moved up
You got dudes like Corley, Judah, Gatti, Baldomir etc.... None of witch are grade A fighters.. Why does this make him so great?? To be the best don't you have to fight the best?? He hasn't really had a great line up or took a challenge with a fighter in two years, Hasn't stayed consistent!.. So my question is who is the best he beat?? and If you beat a bunch of B and C fighters does that make you an A fighter??


P.S. No Flaming.... Debate or disagree in your post but don't get into an emotional argument..Save it for your momma

There are a lot of opinions about how good his opponents have been, but take a look at who else was out there. Freitas, Casamayor, Hatton and Cotto are the only top guys that he hasn't fought through 140. Hatton turned the fight down a couple times and Arum said he wouldn't put Cotto in with PBF (at the time). I don't think anyone really doubts he'd beat Freitas or Casamayor. So you can question his opposition, but who else was there to fight? He's basically walked through all the best fighters that would get in the ring with him.