PBF.. whos the best he beat??

[Sin City]

And what about Sharmba Mitchell? TOP fighter, even though Tszyu probably finished him.

Wasn't he TKO'd twice by Kostya and also KO'd by two not so great fighters before him though.

[Williamb45]

His best opposition was in the Lightweight devision..
Jesus Chavez
Jose Luis Castillo
Diego Corrales
those are the main ones I can think of..
As a Lightweight I give him credit but when he moved up
You got dudes like Corley, Judah, Gatti, Baldomir etc.... None of witch are grade A fighters.. Why does this make him so great?? To be the best don't you have to fight the best?? He hasn't really had a great line up or took a challenge with a fighter in two years, Hasn't stayed consistent!.. So my question is who is the best he beat?? and If you beat a bunch of B and C fighters does that make you an A fighter??


P.S. No Flaming.... Debate or disagree in your post but don't get into an emotional argument..Save it for your momma

Who were the A class fighters that were available that he chose not to fight?? And please don't mention margarito.

[Nacho_Analstain]

i would say jose luis castillo or zab judah

more jose though,jose has fought some excellent fighters and is a true warrior,floyd didnt have an easy time with him in the first fight but the second fight was a different story

[GEOFFHAYES]

Wasn't he TKO'd twice by Kostya

No shame in that

Tszyu's the greatest 140lber of all-time, and probably had the most dangerous right hand of all-time.

[Guest]

His best wins are against a prime Castillo twice.

What "A" fighters did Mayweather avoid? It's more like they avoided him...

[GEOFFHAYES]

Who were the A class fighters that were available that he chose not to fight?? And please don't mention margarito.

Exactly. And let's not forget Hamed and Hatton turned down Mayweather time and again.

Hamed around '99-'00 and Hatton around '03-'04.

[Run]

His best wins are against a prime Castillo twice.

Yeah that first fight goes down as a victory on paper. Floyd didn't win that fight. Castillo 116-112.



Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!

[Sin City]

Who were the A class fighters that were available that he chose not to fight?? And please don't mention margarito.

True theres not many options out there at this time but he could of fought a guy like Hatton or Cotto some one fresh and who have alot of support and are also undefeated it would add more to his resume than Carlos Baldomir..or a shot Gatti.

[Sin City]

Yeah that first fight goes down as a victory on paper. Floyd didn't win that fight. Castillo 116-112.

I dont think he won the first one either but the second he did.

[Nacho_Analstain]

True theres not many options out there at this time but he could of fought a guy like Hatton or Cotto some one fresh and who have alot of support and are also undefeated it would add more to his resume than Carlos Baldomir..or a shot Gatti.

carlos baldomir doesnt look very well on his record,but remmber the time of the fight,everybody was confused,we sort of knew floyd would school him,but there was that feeling in the back of our minds after seing baldy destroy gatti and nearly stop judah