Cotto is definitely top 10 p4p now

[PRsDontEatGlove]

? Hatton is OVERrated. He wrestled with Tzu...what else? Collazo beat his ass. What else?? Tick tock....

Cotto is a level above Hatton. Cotto is a Boxer Hattan is WWF. Cotto will leave him slit faced and pink in under 7 rounds. TKO. He may have a good chin, but his face will tear open and let him down.

[Mishra100]

1.Manny Pacquiao
2.jermain taylor- He beat Bhop who could be anyone #1
3.floyd mayweather jr
4.Ronald Wright
5.Marco Antonio Barrera
6.Juan Manuel Marquez
7.Miguel Cotto
8.Ricky Hatton
9.B Hopkins- Retired or Not----- Could go up or down
10.Oscar De La Hoya

Taylor-
Hopkins (twice)
Joppy

Wright-
Mosley (twice)
quartey
trinidad
Hernandez
Candelo
McKart (twice)
Vargas (should be a win)


How can it even compare?

[Mr. Ryan]

I was just thinking about it and the only thing keeping Cotto from being top 6-7 is a big name victory. That's the only thing keeping Hatton ahead of him on my list. I'm strongly considering whether or not to put Cotto ahead of Calzaghe, who also has no big wins but has been undefeated forever and a day. Cotto's opposition is as good as Calzaghe's so it's close. I don't know why I didn't have Cotto higher before.

1) Mayweather
2) Wright
3) Pacquiao
4) Taylor
5) Hatton
6) Calzaghe
7) Cotto
8) Barrera
9) Freitas??
10) Castillo??

Last two are up for debate. People I'm considering include Freitas (only 1 loss to Corrales), Castillo (strong resume), and of course Hopkins gets on there probably in front of Hatton if he's still fighting.

What do you guys think about Cotto being on there? Maybe he shouldn't be ahead of Barrera, but I've had Barrera in the bottom half of my list ever since the Pacquiao loss and redemption against Morales.

I dunno, Freitas has retired and his only loss was when he quit. If the going gets tough again, and if he even fights again, he'll quit again probably. Castillo is lost in the game right now, he's all over the place with his weight and pulling out of fights.

Here's my list:

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Winky Wright
4. Marco Antonio Barrera
5. Jermain Taylor
6. Joe Calzaghe
7. Rafael Marquez
8. Ricky Hatton
9. Miguel Cotto
10. Jose Luis Castillo

[OptimusWolf]

I don't think you can really put cotto in the p4p list yet - but he's only a win ocer margarito away from getting onto the bottom half, just below someone like calzaghe. Right now my list would be something like this...

1) PBF
2) Pacman
3) Wright
4) Taylor
5) Hopkins
6) Barrera
7) Calzaghe
8) Hatton
9) R Marquez
10) Castillo

[restless_438]

if Cotto's not in your top 10, he should be very close...

[!optimusprime!]

[QUOTE=Sir_Jose;1966932]If you think Miguel Cotto is top 10 p4p...SHOOT YOURSELF

or stop watching Boxing.. YOU should go shoot yourself,,,,,,,,,,,,,how old are you?..........what is that iron man on your avatar?...........grow up!........you dont even have anything related to boxing on your profile......stop hating........go watch a cartoon or something...little boy, ..the grown ups are talkin.

[!!! Beowulf !!!]

Cotto is definately very talented and will be a great boxer, but a win over Carlos Quintana doesn't make him pound for pound.

[Kid Achilles]

or stop watching Boxing.. YOU should go shoot yourself,,,,,,,,,,,,,how old are you?..........what is that iron man on your avatar?...........grow up!........you dont even have anything related to boxing on your profile......stop hating........go watch a cartoon or something...little boy, ..the grown ups are talkin.

No offense but your name is from the TRANSFORMERS.

[!optimusprime!]

lol....thanks achilles.........lol........thanks for pointing that out...........thats it im outta here.

[Kid Achilles]

Stick around, this forum isn't such a bad place when you weigh the pros and cons carefully. The good outweighs the bad.

And again, no offense taken I hope. The irony of your post was too much; I had to butt in there.