Cotto is definitely top 10 p4p now

[Kball15]

I can't beilive he has Hatton at number 3!!! and Calzaghe at 2!?

You better change that list!

im preeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeetty sure hes kidding. Hes got James Toney in his list...

or does he mean margarito...

either way...

[Undefeated]

im preeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeetty sure hes kidding. Hes got James Toney in his list...

or does he mean margarito...

either way...

IMO Hatton and Calzaghe should be around 9-10.. Calzaghes win over Lacy looks overated now.. As for Hatton.. The man clinches.. He should enter WWE!

[ME123]

1.Manny Pacquiao
2.jermain taylor- He beat Bhop who could be anyone #1
3.floyd mayweather jr
4.Ronald Wright
5.Marco Antonio Barrera
6.Juan Manuel Marquez
7.Miguel Cotto
8.Ricky Hatton
9.B Hopkins- Retired or Not----- Could go up or down
10.Oscar De La Hoya

[Kball15]

IMO Hatton and Calzaghe should be around 9-10.. Calzaghes win over Lacy looks overated now.. As for Hatton.. The man clinches.. He should enter WWE!

Hes only been clinching a bunch recently. And he did a LOT against Callazo cause of that southpaw stance.

And in order to beat castillo, i really dont think he can clinch much at all. Unless he wants to get KOed

Cant really deny Hattons entertainment value... the guy can fight and survive some helacious battles...

[Undefeated]

Hes only been clinching a bunch recently. And he did a LOT against Callazo cause of that southpaw stance.

And in order to beat castillo, i really dont think he can clinch much at all. Unless he wants to get KOed

Cant really deny Hattons entertainment value... the guy can fight and survive some helacious battles...

I think Collazo had done a little more than everyone expected. He should have gone out with the win IMO.. Even a draw would have been good. The scores the judges had.. I felt like shooting all of them. He's been clinching a bunch recently, because he has recently been fighting fighters with names. He can't **** with either. So he clinches.. I do not get entertained watching this man fight. He would probaly make it entertaining at moments but then end it with a clinch!

[DiegoFuego]

im preeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeetty sure hes kidding. Hes got James Toney in his list...

or does he mean margarito...

either way...

do you not think a former middleweight who is 40 years old and fat as **** that can beat pretty much all the heavyweights is not p4p material? how long have you been watching boxing?

[moy22487]

1. Mayweather
2. Calzaghe
3. Hatton
4. Pacquaio
5. Barrera
6. Cotto
7. Taylor
8. De La Hoya
9. Toney
10. Castillo


That's based on ability, which it always used to be (until this 'opposition obsession').

On your list from 3 to 6 should be behind tony and de la hoya

[moy22487]

Wow some p4p list on this thread are funny.

[realheavyhands]

everybodies jumping on the cotto bandwagon for no damn reason... he was beat by chop chop if it wasnt in pourto rico he would of lost .. and chop cjop only weighed 138 on fight night.. some people are just ******ed

[The Surgeon]

probably means you just follow what everyone else says...did you REALLY have Cotto in your top 10 P4P before this post was made?

Yeah i had him on for a while now. Follow what every 1 else says? How do work that out when all any1's dun is slag my list? Caldren aint on any1 elses list, Cassamayor is on hardly any1's! Look, Every fighter on every list on this topic is the **** but at the end of the day its all subjective plus u have 2be so Brutal making ur choices!