Cotto is definitely top 10 p4p now

[Undefeated]

[QUOTE=TheEvilSaint;1967236]oh bull****. all he does is lunge his arm out and leave his head wide open for a counter.

dont tell me you honestly havent seen jabs from joe louis, muhammad ali, larry holmes, sonny liston, and tommy hearns? if taylor's got one of the best jabs you've seen, you havent seen ****.

well, of course you havent seen ****. beyond UK fighters and the SMW division, you probly havent seen anything.[/QUOTE]



OOh man...HAHA


But still.. If anyone doesn't have Taylor on their P4P list.. I don't know what to say..

[Hydro]

He has one of the best jabs I've seen.

His jab isn't even one of the most impressive in recent years.

DLH, Quartey, Lewis, Wlad, Barrera, Wright, Whitaker, Foreman, and Mayweather all had better jabs.

[The Fix]

If you think Miguel Cotto is top 10 p4p...SHOOT YOURSELF

or stop watching Boxing..

im co-signing the hell out of this statement...

[TyrantT316]

Heres mine, 2NITE! Its frequently changing!

1# Mayweather

2# Wright

3# Pacquiao

4# Hopkins

5# Taylor

6# Cotto

7# Cassamayor

8# Barrera

9# Calzaghie

10# Calderon

probably means you just follow what everyone else says...did you REALLY have Cotto in your top 10 P4P before this post was made?

[DiegoFuego]

1) Floyd Mayweather Jr.
2) Manny Pacquiao
3) Winky Wright
4) Jermain Taylor
5) Marco Antionio Barrera
6) Bernard Hopkins
7) Joe Calzaghe
8) Ricky Hatton
9) Rafael Marquez
10) Miguel Cotto

one of the better lists I've seen so far. Thanks for actually providing a list unlike half these know-it-all's who say Cotto isn't top 10 but fail to provide a list to prove me wrong.

[DiegoFuego]

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Winky Wright
4. Jermain Taylor (groan)
5. Marco Antonio Barrera
6. Rafael Marquez
7. Miguel Cotto
8. Shane Mosley
9. Joe Calzaghe (groan)
10. Wlad Klitschko

thats mine. cotto's #7 in my p4p and i think hes on his way up.

I respect your list. My one concern is everyone with Rafael Marquez being so high. I have no idea why that is considering any division below featherweight is pretty much devoid of respectable fighters. I guess it's because he's the only one down there knocking people out.

[DiegoFuego]

1. Mayweather
2. Calzaghe
3. Hatton4. Pacquaio
5. Barrera
6. Cotto
7. Taylor
8. De La Hoya
9. Toney
10. Castillo


That's based on ability, which it always used to be (until this 'opposition obsession').

LMAO, you don't even have Wright in your list!

[Kball15]

Why does almost EVERYONE have R. MARQUEZ in their top 10, and not Juan Manuel Marquez?

A list is about skill and these two are SO close in talent! Why does NOBODY have this guy in their lists over Rafael?

I think Rafael is better, id have him anywhere from 8-10. But u'd think SOMEBODY would have Juan, no?

[Kball15]

one of the better lists I've seen so far. Thanks for actually providing a list unlike half these know-it-all's who say Cotto isn't top 10 but fail to provide a list to prove me wrong.

Why is everyone on a Pacquioa high? He beat a guy that was done before the fight started.

Wright Beat a legitimate Fighter who just came off a 'win' against Forrest, another VERY legitimate fighter.

And not only did Wright beat him, he schooled the veteran.

Id have Wright over Pac as of now. Maybe id switch it after they both fight again, but WRIGHT at 2 and PAC at 3

[Undefeated]

LMAO, you don't even have Wright in your list!

I can't beilive he has Hatton at number 3!!! and Calzaghe at 2!?

You better change that list!