how is your pound for pound list now?

[Nacho_Analstain]

Explain why this list would be the poorest....

its just confused me,why is mayweather at number 3?and taylor at number 2?

[ELPacman]

its just confused me,why is mayweather at number 3?and taylor at number 2?

Not everyone likes to ride Mayweather's nuts. Don't be afraid to throw Mayweather as low as you guys want. The man has skills though he is boring, doesn't give a **** about wasting ur PPV money, takes the fights he only knows he can win, and talks like he's #1. A man like that doesn't need to be anywhere near #1. You gotta take REAL risks to be #1

[Shanus]

1.PBF
2.Pacman
3.Winky
4.JT
5.Calzaghe
6.B-Hop
7.M.A.B
8.Hatton
9.Mosley
10.R.Marquez

[kg21mvp]

1.PBF
2.PAC
3.winky
4.JT
5.rafa
6.cotto
7.calzaghe
8.barrera
9.hatton
10.JLC

[loui_ludwig]

Has there ever been a cruiserweight fighter at P4P rankings?

[Super_Lightweight]

In the rematch, MAB clearly beat Rocky, can't say that about JT in his rematch with Taylor, JT won but it was a boring fight. And his draw with Winky, Wright won that fight.

Many people disagree about the Wright fight. The opinion was pretty much split and the fight was close either way. Also, no matter how you examine this, Rocky Juarez Monkey Fana is not on the level of guys like Hopkins and Wright.

[ME123]

Mayweather vs Taylor in competition- I would take Taylor, he beat Hopkins twice regardless of what we all agree or disagree, a win is a win and fought to a draw with Wright. Mayweather doesnt do enough, Yes he has the talent, speed and everything else but the guy will take your money everytime. He doesnt fight with his heart he fight just to win- Boring.

I guess the question should be what is the definition of pound for pound we all will come up with our own. so I guess the real question here is who do you enjoy to watch and who will give you the most for your money everytime?

[realheavyhands]

People may disagree with my 3 and 4 but oh well...


1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Jermain Taylor(if he wins Saturday)
4. Winky Wright(if Taylor loses I put Winky at #3)
5. Marco Antonio Barrera

taylor is bigger then winky wright moved up and beat him .. wright needs to move back down..

[mikec]

1. PBF
2. Pac man
3. Winky
4. Taylor
5. Marquez
6. Calderon
7. Joe C
8. Barrera
9. JLC
10. Corrales


close to this list is Cotto, Casaymoyor, Klitchsko, Hatton (even though he hasnt beat ****)

[TheGR8TESTOAT]

1)Pac Man & PBF (tied)
2)Jermain Taylor
3) Winky