how is your pound for pound list now?

[Super_Lightweight]

It's very close at the top 3-4. I don't buy into P4P lists totally, but here is what I would have.

1) Manny Pacquiao
2) Winky Wright/ Floyd Mayweather
4) Jermain Taylor
5) Ricky Hatton
6) Bernard Hopkins
7) Rafael Marquez
8) Jose Luis Castillo
9) Marco Antonio Barerra
10) Joe Calzaghe

[Kball15]

u gotta have the hatton in their there!!!!

MAYBE, casamayor at 10

Or one of the marquez's at 10. Depending on which one you think is better. After JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ's last performance, im likin him.

[loui_ludwig]

Can't believed some of u are ranking Taylor at 3 or 4. I will ranked MAB over him. Taylor does not deserved to be in the top 10. Just look at his last 3 fights. Controversial win over BHOP, rematch is boring. And who the hell celebrates when the judges declared his fight against Winky? Only Jermain. U can see before the judges announced the result, JT was worried cuz he knew he lost then suddenly jumping up and down when he heard the draw, like he won the fight. Gents, that kind of fighter does not deserve to be top 10.

Another controversial win or draw for JT in his next fight. We will see...............

[Super_Lightweight]

MAB had close fights against Rocky Juarez.

Taylor had close fights against Bernard Hopkins.

Think about this for a second.

[ME123]

1.Manny Pacquiao
2.jermain taylor- He beat Bhop who could be anyone #1
3.floyd mayweather jr
4.Ronald Wright
5.Marco Antonio Barrera
6.Juan Manuel Marquez
7.Miguel Cotto
8.Ricky Hatton
9.B Hopkins- Retired or Not----- Could go up or down
10.Oscar De La Hoya


When I made my list, it can be subjected to changes based on activity, competition, Ko's, wins and style points.. I want fighters who will fight its their job not take my money.. Winky could fall, so can Mayweather. Everyone else will always give you what you paid for

[Kball15]

MAB had close fights against Rocky Juarez.

Taylor had close fights against Bernard Hopkins.

Think about this for a second.

you make a very good point. Except the 2nd Juarez fight wasnt very close at all. But the 2nd hopkins fight was pretty clear as well i guess...

I would definetly have Taylor ahead of Barrera, but only by a slot or maybe 2.

I would have Hatton at 7, Barrera at 6, and Taylor at 5ish. Maybe move everyone back one. idk

[loui_ludwig]

MAB had close fights against Rocky Juarez.

Taylor had close fights against Bernard Hopkins.

Think about this for a second.

Don't need a second to think about it.

In the rematch, MAB clearly beat Rocky, can't say that about JT in his rematch with Taylor, JT won but it was a boring fight. And his draw with Winky, Wright won that fight.

[Nacho_Analstain]

1.Manny Pacquiao
2.jermain taylor- He beat Bhop who could be anyone #1
3.floyd mayweather jr
4.Ronald Wright
5.Marco Antonio Barrera
6.Juan Manuel Marquez
7.Miguel Cotto
8.Ricky Hatton
9.B Hopkins- Retired or Not----- Could go up or down
10.Oscar De La Hoya


When I made my list, it can be subjected to changes based on activity, competition, Ko's, wins and style points.. I want fighters who will fight its their job not take my money.. Winky could fall, so can Mayweather. Everyone else will always give you what you paid for

thats 1 of the poorest p4p lists i have ever seen

[ME123]

Explain why this list would be the poorest....

[Mishra100]

1/2/3 Wright, Pac, Mayweather (whatever position you want them in... they all have different qualities... Pac has excitement and knockouts, Wright has the resume, and Mayweather has the domination)
4. Barrera
5. Taylor
6. Calzaghe
7. Hopkins
8. Mosley
9. Hatton
10. Toney