how is your pound for pound list now?

[Nacho_Analstain]

1. floyd mayweather jr

2. manny pacquiao

3. ronald wright

4. jermain taylor

5. marco antonio barerra

6. bernard hopkins

7.oscar de la hoya

8. joe calzaghe

9. shane mosley

10. joel casamayor

yours?

[frank THE tank]

around the same as your but wouldnt have mosley or de la hoya in it

would definitely have castillo in it

[Cambria]

1. PBF
2. Winky
3. Taylor (Assuming he Wins Saturday)
4. Pacman
5. Barrera
6. Calzaghe
7. B-hop
8. R. Marquez
9. J.M. Marquez
10. Cotto

[mikefromstu]

1. floyd mayweather jr

2. manny pacquiao

3. ronald wright

4. jermain taylor

5. marco antonio barerra

6. bernard hopkins

7.oscar de la hoya

8. joe calzaghe

9. shane mosley

10. joel casamayor

yours?

Fine list but i think that after his last twoo performances Cotto should be in there. Oscar should not and nor should mosley. Rafel Marquez is top five.
I would go like this
1.PBF
2.Pac-Man
3.Winky
4.Taylor
5.R. Marquez
6.Joe C
7.B Hop
8.MAB
9.Cassamayor
10. Cotto

[Njord777]

1. PBF
2. Winky
3. Taylor (Assuming he Wins Saturday)
4. Pacman
5. Barrera
6. Calzaghe
7. B-hop
8. R. Marquez
9. J.M. Marquez
10. Cotto

I can see your logic with this list, not knocking it, but I'm not sure I would personally put Taylor above Pac-man even if he does win. I think all the lists thus far make sense. They can carry an argument.

[-EX-]

People may disagree with my 3 and 4 but oh well...


1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Jermain Taylor(if he wins Saturday)
4. Winky Wright(if Taylor loses I put Winky at #3)
5. Marco Antonio Barrera

[Njord777]

People may disagree with my 3 and 4 but oh well...


1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Jermain Taylor(if he wins Saturday)
4. Winky Wright(if Taylor loses I put Winky at #3)
5. Marco Antonio Barrera

You're hurting me by putting Winky below Taylor. I think fighting a younger, stronger champion in Taylor and then a tough old veteran like Quartey puts him at #3. Jermain Taylor needs to fight other young bulls before I put him up in my rankings. Ouma couldn't hurt Taylor with a lead pipe wedged in his glove.

[Parody]

Ouma couldn't hurt Taylor with a lead pipe wedged in his glove.

Nor could Quartey (who moved from Welter to Middleweight) hurt Winky, a bigger stronger fighter

[Njord777]

Nor could Quartey (who moved from Welter to Middleweight) hurt Winky, a bigger stronger fighter

I see your point, but at Winky's age I'll suck him off for fighting anyone decent. I suppose I don't have faith that he won't hit the canvas someday soon.

[Rudyo]

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Ronald Wright
3. Manny Pacquiao
4. Marco Antonio Barrera
5. Rafeal Marquez
6. Joe Calzaghe
7. Ricky Hatton
8. Joel Casamayor
9. Jose Luis Castillo
10. Shane Mosley
11. Jermain Taylor
12. Miguel Cotto
13. Juan Manuel Marquez
14. Oscar De La Hoya
15. Jorge Arce
16. Chris John
17. Isral Vazquez
18. Pongsaklek Wonjogkam
19. Juan Diaz
20. Mikkel Kessler

I made it to 20 cause I'm ballin' like that.