As a pro, Lewis's prime was in full flower twice when two so-so heavyweights knocked him cold. In an all time top 5 heavyweight this cannot be. It means if you are good the rest of the way, you make it into the top 10, probably not higher. And the same thing really goes for Vlad, too. He went out a couple of times. Top 5ers don't do that. Dempsey's loss to Flynn was way early on, and does not compare. That was when Jack was starving and hoboing around.
Though he was normally dominant and beat a good variety of tough fighters, he had that susceptibility to punches. However, he was not that easy to land on. A smaller guy like Tua he could completely shut down. But when big punches could get through, he showed a clear susceptibility to gnaw canvas.
Ironically, the two KOs which smudge his legacy were temporary setbacks after which he resumed his dominance, gaining partial redemption for his legacy, getting back about seventy-five cents for every dollar he lost. He showed considerable character in restoring himself twice from wedge-of-cucumber status, but not enough to gain back what he lost. At the upper eschelons of all time greatness beard is king, for it must be assumed that fellow ATGs will nearly always find a way to land their best on you, or they would be otherwise than all time greats. At the all time level, you simply have to be able to take it as well as dish it out. To me, that is why Lewis is not a top 5 heavyweight.
Though he was normally dominant and beat a good variety of tough fighters, he had that susceptibility to punches. However, he was not that easy to land on. A smaller guy like Tua he could completely shut down. But when big punches could get through, he showed a clear susceptibility to gnaw canvas.
Ironically, the two KOs which smudge his legacy were temporary setbacks after which he resumed his dominance, gaining partial redemption for his legacy, getting back about seventy-five cents for every dollar he lost. He showed considerable character in restoring himself twice from wedge-of-cucumber status, but not enough to gain back what he lost. At the upper eschelons of all time greatness beard is king, for it must be assumed that fellow ATGs will nearly always find a way to land their best on you, or they would be otherwise than all time greats. At the all time level, you simply have to be able to take it as well as dish it out. To me, that is why Lewis is not a top 5 heavyweight.
Comment