All Time Greatest Fighters by Division

[The Old LefHook]

Dempsey--heavyweight

Conn--light heavyweight

Greb--middleweight

Walker--welterweight

Duran--lightweight

Pep--Featherweight

Jofre--bantamweight

[rightsideup]

ali or Louis at hw
Charles at lhw
monzon or Robinson at middle
Robinson at welter
Duran or Leonard at lightweight
pep at feather
zartate at Bantam

[IronDanHamza]

Maybe we could add the other weight classes in too?

My orginal 8 for now;

Heavyweight - Muhammad Ali

Light Heavyweightt - Ezzard Charles

Middleweight - Carlos Monzon

Welterweight - Ray Robinson

Lightweight - Benny Leonard

Featherweight - Henry Armstrong

Bantamweight - Struggling, but probably go with Eder Jofre

Flyweight - Miguel Canto

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Heavy Ali

Light heavy Michael spinks

Middleweight Marvin hagler

Welter Ray robinson

Lightweight Duran

Feather Armstrong

Bantam Zarate

Flyweight Miguel canto

[rightsideup]

I amend my feather pick to Armstrong Never thought much about his championship in that division.

[JimEarl]

Maybe we could add the other weight classes in too?

Muhammad Ali - HW

Evander Holyfield - CW

Ezzard Charles - LHW

Joe Calzaghe - SMW

Marvin Haggler - MW

Thomas Hearns - LMW

Ray Robinson - WW

Aaron Pryor - JWW

Joe Gans - LW

Floyd Mayweather Jr - SFW

Sandy Saddler - FeatherWeight

Wilfredo Gomez -SBW

Carlos Zarate - BW

Johnny Tapia - JBW

Pongsaklek Wonjongkam - FlyWeight

[joeandthebums]

Only two I never change opinion on are Louis and Robinson.

All with exception of Robinson I think have credible alternatives.

HW - Joe Louis
LHW- Ezzard Charles
MW - Harry Greb
WW - Ray Robinson
LW - Joe Gans
FW - Sandy Saddler
BW - Eder Jofre
FLY - Jimmy Wilde

[Galileo]

HW - Ali
CW - Holyfield
LHW - E.Charles
MW - R.Robinson
LMW - T.Hearns
WW - R.Robinson
SLW - A.Pryor
LW - R.Duran
FW - S.Sadler
BW. - E.Jofre
FW - J.Wilde

[IronDanHamza]

I'll try;

Cruiserweight - Evander Holyfield

Super Middleweight - Carl Froch

Jr Middleweight - Mike McCallum

Jr Welterweight - Julio Cesar Chavez

Jr Lightweight - Floyd Mayweather

Jr Featherweight - Wilfredo Gomez

Jr Bantamweight - Not sure

Minimumweight - Ricardo Lopez

[D-MiZe]

Super Middleweight - Carl Froch

I entered this thread with one mission and one mission alone, to raise the question about the 168lb division...

Why Froch and not Ward?

I think my top 3 for SMW would be,

Ward
Froch
Calzaghe