Is Antonio Margarito a Hall of Famer?

[ShoulderRoll]

Cheaters don't deserve to get that kind of recognition in my opinion. But putting aside "the scandal" was his career good enough to get him in?

[Sugar Adam Ali]

No...

The cotto win was great, but other than that he is severely overrated..

Bob arums smoke and mirrors worked wonders with margarito as he feasted on young green guys for most of his career..

People make him out to be a monster that would crush everyone late in a fight but in reality he struggled everytime he stepped up..
Never got a win vs santos in either fight
Lost to paul Williams
Barely survived a one handed clottey
Beaten down by sugar shane
Beaten down by manny
Lost the cotto rematch

Oh, but he beat cintron... Lmao Def not a hall of famer and one of the most overrated guys of the past decade or so

[jas]

Absolutely not

And he wont get in because of the cheating

[LacedUp]

Cheaters don't deserve to get that kind of recognition in my opinion. But putting aside "the scandal" was his career good enough to get him in?

No. Not at all.

No discussion is needed.

[Hype job]

But you're ok with the PED using brotha Mosley getting inducted into the HOF doe.

[Scott9945]

I was a fan of his. But even if you disregard the plaster incident, he still doesn't measure up to be in the HOF.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

I do really wish that him and floyd fought in 2006.. Margs isn't top shelf, but his style and size would give floyd all he could handle.. Would have loved to seen how floyd handled it..

Also I always wanted to see margs vs mayorga... The 2 bad boy villians of boxing throwing down in an epic fight

[LacedUp]

But you're ok with the PED using brotha Mosley getting inducted into the HOF doe.

So uneducated.

Regardless, Mosley had a much better career than margarito, whichever way you want to put it.

[ShoulderRoll]

But you're ok with the PED using brotha Mosley getting inducted into the HOF doe.

?

I think Shane was a very good fighter but I've never condoned his PED use.

[rightsideup]

no he does not