Vitali

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Herbie Hide (WBO champ)
Timo Hoffmann (European champ)
Ross Purrity
Corrie Sanders (WBC champ)
Danny Williams
Samuel Peter (WBC champ)
Juan Carlos Gomez
Chris Arreola
Kevin Johnson
Shannon Briggs
Odlanier Solis
Tomasz Adamek
Dereck Chisora

I think I can help him...It turns out Vitali fought a lot of owl men. I think you will see what I mean as I present this best list of all time....

1, Manuel who?

2, Albert Who?

3.Juan Carlos....Who!??

4. Kirk who!????

5. Timo.......Timo....Who!!!??

6. Ed Who?

And many more owl men as well. Woo woo hooo

To be fair, vitali's best/solid wins are
Herbie
Sanders
Peter
Aerreola
Adamek
Chisora


None are really spectacular in historical terms but at the time they were solid dominant wins over highly ranked guys,, all were top 10 and some top 5.. All it shows is that vitali was a solid champ but nothing else.. Comparable in terms of championship reigns he is in the same league as an genaro hernadez, ike quartey kosta tszyu- good champs but short on big career wins to truly have an atg resume

[BKM-2010]

Sanders is his best win.

[Weltschmerz]

Sanders is his best win.

All of his wins were good. The Sanders win was good, of course. I actually like some of his late performances in particular. Adamek, Chisora, Arreola.

[LacedUp]

To be fair, vitali's best/solid wins are
Herbie
Sanders
Peter
Aerreola
Adamek
Chisora


None are really spectacular in historical terms but at the time they were solid dominant wins over highly ranked guys,, all were top 10 and some top 5.. All it shows is that vitali was a solid champ but nothing else.. Comparable in terms of championship reigns he is in the same league as an genaro hernadez, ike quartey kosta tszyu- good champs but short on big career wins to truly have an atg resume

Neither Hide mor Chisora were top 10.

For all his knockouts and wins, Vitali has generally fought the second tier of the heavyweight division. Johnson, Charr, Chisora, Sosnowski, Briggs etc. it sure doesn't make for nice reading.

He has 6 top 10 wins in his career. That's unfortunately not all time greatness.

[LacedUp]

His best win was Sam Peter. In my opinion a better win than Sanders.

That says a lot.

[Weltschmerz]

Neither Hide mor Chisora were top 10.

For all his knockouts and wins, Vitali has generally fought the second tier of the heavyweight division. Johnson, Charr, Chisora, Sosnowski, Briggs etc. it sure doesn't make for nice reading.

He has 6 top 10 wins in his career. That's unfortunately not all time greatness.

How did you get this number?

[IronDanHamza]

Herbie Hide (WBO champ)
Timo Hoffmann (European champ)
Ross Purrity
Corrie Sanders (WBC champ)
Danny Williams
Samuel Peter (WBC champ)
Juan Carlos Gomez
Chris Arreola
Kevin Johnson
Shannon Briggs
Odlanier Solis
Tomasz Adamek
Dereck Chisora

A lot of those weren't the top contenders and even if they were that's a very poor resume there.

[New England]

Herbie Hide (WBO champ)
Timo Hoffmann (European champ)
Ross Purrity
Corrie Sanders (WBC champ)
Danny Williams
Samuel Peter (WBC champ)
Juan Carlos Gomez
Chris Arreola
Kevin Johnson
Shannon Briggs
Odlanier Solis
Tomasz Adamek
Dereck Chisora

ATG resume right there.

[Weltschmerz]

A lot of those weren't the top contenders and even if they were that's a very poor resume there.

ATG resume right there.

As I've explained previously, I don't just rank greatness on resume. A poster asked me to give some names he beat, which I did.

[New England]

As I've explained previously, I don't just rank greatness on resume. A poster asked me to give some names he beat, which I did.

klitschko fans [mostly vitali,] are known for designing their own criteria for determining greatness. hell, they even do it for wins / losses


saying that "vitali is an ATG" makes you feel good. when it's established that he doesn't fit the criteria of an ATG, you use your own. when he loses a fight via stoppage (byrd, lewis,) you make up your own rules.


bro, i get it. believe me. do your thing.