rank these 3,, Argeullo, camacho, jmm

[Sugar Adam Ali]

how would you rank these 3 guys:

alexis argeullo

hector camacho

juan manuel marquez


based on total career resume:::

[Scott9945]

how would you rank these 3 guys:

alexis argeullo

hector camacho

juan manuel marquez


based on total career resume:::

Arguello

Marquez

Camacho

[Anthony342]

Arguello

Marquez

Camacho

Yeah this.

[DBSLM]

I agree Arguello, JMM, Camacho as far as accomplishments but Camacho might have the style to beat both. Lets remember Alexis was outboxed by Violomar Fernandez & JMM was outboxed by John & had a tough time with Casamayor

[GeneralZod]

Arguello
Marquez
Macho

Camacho does have the style to at least win a decision over both, not that'd he'd dominate though.

[IronDanHamza]

Arguello

Marquez

Camacho

That's the order and I don't think it's arguable.

[Salardo]

I agree Arguello, JMM, Camacho as far as accomplishments but Camacho might have the style to beat both. Lets remember Alexis was outboxed by Violomar Fernandez & JMM was outboxed by John & had a tough time with Casamayor

Outboxed? On my scorecard Marquez won that fight. I just watched it a few weeks ago.

As for the ranking: the first thing I thought was
1. Arguello
2. Marquez
3. Camacho

[Humean]

Definitely Arguello first but I might have Camacho ahead of Marquez, i'd certainly pick prime Camacho over prime Marquez in a match up. In terms of their career resume I think it is close. I think Marquez is a guy that far too many on this forum give the benefit of the doubt to which they never seem to give to others. If you honestly believe Marquez beat Norwood, John, Bradley and won all the Pacquiao fights then his resume is definitely better than Camacho. If you think his 'official' record on these fights were pretty much just then I think you could make a case for Camacho over Marquez.

[rightsideup]

Outboxed? On my scorecard Marquez won that fight. I just watched it a few weeks ago.

As for the ranking: the first thing I thought was
1. Arguello
2. Marquez
3. Camacho

I think this is correct in accordance to accomplishments but they are extremely close

[Sugar Adam Ali]

i think jmm has the biggest win out of the three, but i also think he loses to both guys,, a camacho of the 80s i think would beat jmm,, especially pre-rosario fight,, Camacho seemed to change his style after that fight to more of a boxing on the outside type fighter