Charley Burley or Holman Williams

[RubenSonny]

Who has the greater resume?

[rightsideup]

Williams more loses but better comp and 15 rd win over burly

[RubenSonny]

Williams more loses but better comp and 15 rd win over burly

Gladly agreed, as far as I know most people rate Burley higher but I don't see it that way.

[IronDanHamza]

Great topic.

I think it's debatable, I'm going solely off the top of my head but both have top calibur ATG resumes.

[NChristo]

It's definitely close I'd probably side with Williams although Burley was a lot more consistent, both have ATG resumes, hard too split them imo.

[rightsideup]

It's definitely close I'd probably side with Williams although Burley was a lot more consistent, both have ATG resumes, hard too split them imo.

I was swayed toward williams because on his bio on boxrec it mentioned he faced many a great fighter with bad hands and had decent power before his injuries but there is no wrong choice on this topic as both fellows were amazing fighters.

[The Surgeon]

Holman's is probably SLIGHTLY more impressive. Everybody in and around boxing has at least heard of Burley if they dont know him inside out but only a small portion of fans even acknowledge the EXISTENCE of Williams! Shame...

[greynotsoold]

I've read that Holman Williams was very influential in the development of both Joe Louis and Eddie Futch.