Greater Fighter...Barney Ross or Rocky Marciano?

[Perfect Plex]

Who should be ranked higher on a ATG list and why?

[JAB5239]

Who should be ranked higher on a ATG list and why?

Ross, and its not even close. He beat prime versions of two of the best fighters in the wold p4p at the time in Canzoneri and McLarnin and sports a far superior resume. Marciano is on of my favorites but I don't think he makes the top 50, while Ross easily cracks the top 25.

[RINGG]

I voted for Ross as the better fighter. I feel Marciano was not a great fighter. He was very strong and had tremendous stamina, power and had a great heart. However I think Marciano did great things and was the ultimate over achiever.

[NChristo]

Barney Ross.

[Perfect Plex]

Wow, Ross winning 4-0. Ring Magazine & Bert Sugar both had Marciano higher by a few places.

[RubenSonny]

Wow, Ross winning 4-0. Ring Magazine & Bert Sugar both had Marciano higher by a few places.

Just because Marciano is more famous.

[Perfect Plex]

Just because Marciano is more famous.

Surely do Ring Magazine & even Bert would look past this? Ring did have Monzon & Whitaker higher than Marciano, and he's more famous than them.

[RubenSonny]

Surely do Ring Magazine & even Bert would look past this? Ring did have Monzon & Whitaker higher than Marciano, and he's more famous than them.

Well thats strange, I just assumed that would be the reason. Sugar has been biased for a long time though.