Ranking Hopkins Over Hagler, Can It Be Justified?

[Perfect Plex]

And does any actually think Hopkins should be ranked higher on a ATG list?

[Toney616]

yes it is justified,haglers only worthy win came against hearns,hopkins would actually dismiss hagler rather quickly within 3 rounds,

Stop trolling.

[Joey Giardello]

If hopkins beats pascal am gonna rank him higher than hagler

[$Bullsfam$]

Definitely can be justified just for the simple fact that Hopkins is a mastermind in the ring. If he mad it ugly he definitely could pull it off.

But no I wouldn't rank him above Hagler unless of course he beat Pascal & Dawson.

[JAB5239]

If hopkins beats pascal am gonna rank him higher than hagler

P4p it would be justified doing this, but not at middleweight. Do you not agree?

[Joey Giardello]

P4p it would be justified doing this, but not at middleweight. Do you not agree?

I rank hagler higher as a middleweight, but if hopkins beats pascal i rank hopkins better as the over all fighter

[joseph5620]

P4p it would be justified doing this, but not at middleweight. Do you not agree?

That's exactly how I see it Jab. Overall career, yes. Middleweight,no.

[r.burgundy]

hopkins is better than hagler without pascal.p4p and in mw.both their biggest wins at m.w were against blown up welters,so tito and tommy cancel out.after leonard and oscar their records are pedestrian and pretty much even.i believe hopkins fought the better fighters overall a mw but not by much but hagler should definitely be ehind hopkins

[Toney616]

hopkins is better than hagler without pascal.p4p and in mw.

I would argue that Hagler faced a better level of opposition

both their biggest wins at m.w were against blown up welters,.

I would argue that Hagler biggest win was over the like of Monroe, Briscoe and maybe Roldan. Hearns hadnt proved anything at mw when he fought Hagler

so tito and tommy cancel out.after leonard and oscar their records are pedestrian and pretty much even.

Hearns has a better resume that Tito, Duran was a better mw than Oscar

i believe hopkins fought the better fighters overall a mw but not by much but hagler should definitely be ehind hopkins

Hopkins best wins
Tarver
the little guys

[sonnyboyx2]

Both can only be rated at Middleweight and both are great fighters with Hagler having by far the better resume at 160 so he rates ahead of BHop...