Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The 5 Greatest Fighters Of The Last 30 Years

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #11
    Originally posted by Sugarj View Post
    Would you honestly rate Oscar over Tommy Hearns?
    Sugarj it depends how you want to rate them, personally no i would not but the thread ask's who the 5 greatest fighters are of the last 30yrs and if you go by PPV numbers, titles won, career earnings, fan base etc etc then the 5 fighters i named come out on top.. my own person top 5 would not consist of any of them and most on here would have a field-day with them.

    Comment


    • #12
      Originally posted by sonnyboyx2 View Post
      Sugarj it depends how you want to rate them, personally no i would not but the thread ask's who the 5 greatest fighters are of the last 30yrs and if you go by PPV numbers, titles won, career earnings, fan base etc etc then the 5 fighters i named come out on top.. my own person top 5 would not consist of any of them and most on here would have a field-day with them.
      WTF has career earnings, fan base, & ppv numbers got to do with greatness???

      Greatness should be judged off whats fighters done in the ring, who they beat, there skills & resume. Not how many fans they have or how many PPV numbers they pull in.

      I've only been here a few days. Put your posts always seem to catch my attention. You seem to say alot of things that just dont' make sense imo.
      Last edited by Underrated Jab; 10-20-2010, 11:07 AM.

      Comment


      • #13
        Originally posted by sonnyboyx2 View Post
        Sugarj it depends how you want to rate them, personally no i would not but the thread ask's who the 5 greatest fighters are of the last 30yrs and if you go by PPV numbers, titles won, career earnings, fan base etc etc then the 5 fighters i named come out on top.. my own person top 5 would not consist of any of them and most on here would have a field-day with them.


        I see your angle.

        I suppose I was looking more at a skills angle.

        Comment


        • #14
          Originally posted by Underrated Jab View Post
          WTF has career earnings, fan base, & ppv numbers got to do with greatness???

          Greatness should be judged off whats fighters done in the ring, who they beat, there skills & resume. Not how many fans they have or how many PPV numbers they pull in.

          I've only been here a few days. Put your posts always seem to catch my attention. You seem to say alot of things that just dont' make sense imo.
          funny i seem to think the same about your post's..what is it about the fighter's i have listed that you think just don't make sense?

          1/. Manny Pacquiao - world titles in 7 different weight classes and P4P No1

          2/. Roy Jones - world titles in 4 weight classes P4P No1 for a decade, only man in history to start his career at 154lbs and win heavyweight title.

          3/. Mike Tyson - Youngest ever heavyweight champion who regained title a 2nd time, an ATG puncher and boxing phenomenon.

          4/. Ray Leonard - 5 times world champion in 5 weight classes, excellent fighter who beat the best of his era P4P

          5/. Oscar Delahoya - 6 times world champion in 6 weight classes, fought and beat the best of his era as well as being a PPV phenomenon & P4P

          Comment


          • #15
            Originally posted by Underrated Jab View Post
            Mike Tyson over Evander Holyfield, Thomas Hearns, Pernell Whitaker? Oscar De La Hoya over Pernell Whiatker, JCC, Evander Holyfield & Thomas Hearns?
            cough-up your Top 5 to i pull it apart

            Comment


            • #16
              Originally posted by sonnyboyx2 View Post
              funny i seem to think the same about your post's..what is it about the fighter's i have listed that you think just don't make sense?

              1/. Manny Pacquiao - world titles in 7 different weight classes and P4P No1

              2/. Roy Jones - world titles in 4 weight classes P4P No1 for a decade, only man in history to start his career at 154lbs and win heavyweight title.

              3/. Mike Tyson - Youngest ever heavyweight champion who regained title a 2nd time, an ATG puncher and boxing phenomenon.

              4/. Ray Leonard - 5 times world champion in 5 weight classes, excellent fighter who beat the best of his era P4P

              5/. Oscar Delahoya - 6 times world champion in 6 weight classes, fought and beat the best of his era as well as being a PPV phenomenon & P4P
              See your making no sense AGAIN. You said before this isn't your real list?

              my own person top 5 would not consist of any of them
              WTF??????

              And how is Mike Tyson greater than Pernell Whitaker, Thomas Hearns, Julio Cesar Chavez, & Evander Holyfield?

              How is Whitaker, Holyfield, Hearns, Chavez, not in the list, but yet De La Hoya & Tyson are?

              Complete & utter bogus!

              Comment


              • #17
                1. Leonard.
                2. Whitaker
                3. JCC
                4. Duran
                5. Hagler.

                I think Duran is all time great than all the guy I have above him. However, mos of his work came in the 70's. I still think though he put in enough work in the last 30 years to be in the top 5. I just think the 3 I have ahead of him accomplished more during those 30 years period.

                And, I couldn't decide between Hearns, Holyfield, and Hagler for my #5 spot. So I just went with Hagler do to alphabetical order. I think is really close between those 3 and you could just switch them around.
                Last edited by jrosales13; 10-20-2010, 11:28 AM.

                Comment


                • #18
                  Originally posted by Underrated Jab View Post
                  See your making no sense AGAIN. You said before this isn't your real list?



                  WTF??????

                  And how is Mike Tyson greater than Pernell Whitaker, Thomas Hearns, Julio Cesar Chavez, & Evander Holyfield?

                  How is Whitaker, Holyfield, Hearns, Chavez, not in the list, but yet De La Hoya & Tyson are?

                  Complete & utter bogus!
                  ha ha i am trying to think who you are (alias) as it seems your agenda is with me personally... so it won't be difficult to come up with who you really are as we dont get many Lennox Lewis fanboys here in the history section... Maybe General Zod eh.. ha haaa

                  Comment


                  • #19
                    But why do you have Tyson over Whitaker?

                    Comment


                    • #20
                      Originally posted by Underrated Jab View Post
                      But why do you have Tyson over Whitaker?
                      Let's see your list coz i think it will look something like this:

                      Lewis
                      Vitali
                      Calzaghe
                      Hatton
                      Wlad

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X
                      TOP