Joe Frazier Or Michael Spinks?

[gimmeyapudpud]

You simply can't understand that ducking a fight and not making a fight are two entirely different things. If these guys were in a mandatory position and Frazier said no, thats a duck. We all know this isn't the case though. They all got beat while jockeying for position, thats a fact. Frazier is one of the greatest heavyweights ever, you have to learn to live with that and let go of all the bitterness.

If you're going to completely ignore the vast majority of my post,then atleast answer the last part -

If Mac foster,Earnie Shavers and Ron Lyle fought in Louis's era,do you think he would have fought them?

[JAB5239]

If you're going to completely ignore the vast majority of my post,then atleast answer the last part -

If Mac foster,Earnie Shavers and Ron Lyle fought in Louis's era,do you think he would have fought them?

Maybe. Louis was obviously a fighting champion given his 25 defenses. Then again, who's to say? If they were beaten by better contenders and Louis fought them instead, who could blame him?

[frankenfrank]

Michael Spinks : Gerry Cooney , Mike Tyson , Larry Holmes (*2) , Muhammad Qawi , Eddie Mustaffa Muhammad

Joe Frazier : Muhammad Ali (*3) , George Foreman (*2) , Oscar Bonavena (*2) ,
George Chuvalo , Buster Mathis , Jimmy Ellis (*2) , Ron Stander , Jerry Quarry (*2) , Joe Bugner , Doug Jones , Eddie Machen , Bob Foster

who had more important / impressive wins ?
who had more important fights ?
who would have beaten whom in a h2h fight ?

i think the answer is very very clear here.

[boxingbuff]

Michael Spinks : Gerry Cooney , Mike Tyson , Larry Holmes (*2) , Muhammad Qawi , Eddie Mustaffa Muhammad

Joe Frazier : Muhammad Ali (*3) , George Foreman (*2) , Oscar Bonavena (*2) ,
George Chuvalo , Buster Mathis , Jimmy Ellis (*2) , Ron Stander , Jerry Quarry (*2) , Joe Bugner , Doug Jones , Eddie Machen , Bob Foster

who had more important / impressive wins ?
who had more important fights ?
who would have beaten whom in a h2h fight ?

i think the answer is very very clear here.

I don't think people realize how good fighters like Eddie Machen was.I believe Machen would have beat Spinks.There are alot of other fighters you listed who would have beat Spinks as well.