List your top 5 middleweights of all-time

[Schmerzen]

Floyd Mayweather Is Undefeated at Junior Middleweight

1)Floyd Mayweather Jr
2)Floyd Mayweather Jr
3)Floyd Mayweather Jr
4)Floyd Mayweather Jr
5)Floyd Mayweather Jr

You see all those guys on you're list have losses,and everybody's beating each other,but no one has beatin Floyd Mayweather Jr.So that makes him number 1 all time great


Just playing around Ts

this mayweather hate goes too far now, what has this thread to do with him?

anyway my list :

1. Greb & Hagler
2. SRR
3. Monzon
4. La Motta
5. Roy Jones JR.

[frankenfrank]

1. Sam Langford
2. Ray Robinson
3. Marvin Hagler
4. James Toney
5. Carlos Monzon

[JAB5239]

Hagler
Monzon
Greb
Robinson
Burley

[BigStereotype]

SRR
RJJ
B Hop
Jake LaMotta
Monzon

You seriously have B-Hop at 3? And Marvin Hagler's not on your list? What were you thinking?

Sugar Ray Robinson
Marvin Hagler
Harry Greb
Roy Jones Jr.
Jake LaMotta

[JAB5239]

You seriously have B-Hop at 3? And Marvin Hagler's not on your list? What were you thinking?

Sugar Ray Robinson
Marvin Hagler
Harry Greb
Roy Jones Jr.
Jake LaMotta

I see a lot of lists with Roy Jones in the top 5. How can you guys justify that?
He was ultra talented, yes. But what did he really accomplish and who did he beat to be rated so high?

[sonnyboyx2]

SRR
RJJ
B Hop
Jake LaMotta
Monzon

Jake LaMotta is a brave choice, IMO he would not make a Top 10 list

[GJC]

Hagler
Monzon
Greb
Robinson
Burley

Would probably swap Ketchel for Burley although I think I would favour Langford over him head to head. If that makes any sense lol

[macthechamp]

You seriously have B-Hop at 3? And Marvin Hagler's not on your list? What were you thinking?

Sugar Ray Robinson
Marvin Hagler
Harry Greb
Roy Jones Jr.
Jake LaMotta

What's wrong with Hopkins on anyone's list? He's definitely an all-time great middleweight. 20 title defenses and defeated the likes of DLH, Trinidad and G. Johnson in great fashion.

[CarlosG815]

You seriously have B-Hop at 3? And Marvin Hagler's not on your list? What were you thinking?

Sugar Ray Robinson
Marvin Hagler
Harry Greb
Roy Jones Jr.
Jake LaMotta

B Hop would destroy Harry Greb, who is 3 on your list. He also beat Trinidad, De La Hoya, Tarver, Joppy, Winky, and Pavlik.

Come off it, dude. Greb beat Tunney and Walker and you're gonna hate on other people's list? It's all opinion and yours isn't better than anyone else's.

[CarlosG815]

Jake LaMotta is a brave choice, IMO he would not make a Top 10 list

LaMotta had an iron chin, incredible pressuring style and a fierce style of fighting. He's one of the most exciting old school fighters to watch and I think that he has a great chance to beat anybody on any top 10 middleweight list. You can't say that the 5 guys anybody listed would wipe up with LaMotta. He has a great chance to beat anybody in his class.